40:@0.047547:0.056159:0.062749:0.056159:0.062749:0.047246:0.047547:0.047246:0.007473:0.007728
Performance analysis:@0.739062:0.058552:0.904036:0.058552:0.904036:0.047968:0.739062:0.047968:0.010087:0.008826:0.006352:0.006416:0.009992:0.006560:0.014955:0.008587:0.010055:0.007661:0.008970:0.005634:0.008986:0.010087:0.008986:0.004709:0.009066:0.007310:0.004709:0.007023
Cases of note:@0.048807:0.107246:0.196075:0.107246:0.196075:0.091647:0.048807:0.091647:0.014677:0.012278:0.010349:0.012490:0.010349:0.007550:0.013854:0.008726:0.008068:0.013619:0.013854:0.008726:0.012725
Khan v.  Meadows (Supreme:@0.049227:0.128222:0.289331:0.128222:0.289331:0.117080:0.049227:0.117080:0.011593:0.010669:0.009661:0.010753:0.006468:0.008317:0.004200:0.004637:0.003007:0.017641:0.010081:0.009913:0.011509:0.011341:0.014869:0.008149:0.006468:0.006636:0.009997:0.010837:0.011089:0.007140:0.009661:0.016381:0.009089
 :@0.289903:0.128222:0.294506:0.128222:0.294506:0.117080:0.289903:0.117080:0.004603
Court, 18 June 2021):@0.048807:0.143901:0.223269:0.143901:0.223269:0.132759:0.048807:0.132759:0.011257:0.010921:0.010837:0.007224:0.006888:0.004872:0.006468:0.009661:0.009661:0.005628:0.007981:0.010921:0.010921:0.009745:0.006048:0.009661:0.009913:0.009661:0.009997:0.006200
This case concerns the scope of a  medical practitioner's :@0.047967:0.165453:0.445875:0.165453:0.445875:0.154869:0.047967:0.154869:0.008364:0.008683:0.003863:0.006560:0.005634:0.007135:0.007901:0.006767:0.008012:0.005634:0.007374:0.009353:0.009034:0.007374:0.008348:0.005554:0.009034:0.006767:0.005283:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005634:0.006560:0.007135:0.009162:0.009066:0.008060:0.006049:0.009353:0.004756:0.005203:0.006895:0.004373:0.002426:0.013359:0.008060:0.009066:0.003863:0.006975:0.007805:0.003863:0.006720:0.009162:0.005554:0.007805:0.007374:0.005219:0.003863:0.005203:0.003863:0.009082:0.009034:0.008012:0.005554:0.003671:0.006480:0.004373
duty when consulted about a specific issue.:@0.048387:0.181132:0.357057:0.181132:0.357057:0.170548:0.048387:0.170548:0.009401:0.008667:0.005411:0.007725:0.004373:0.011811:0.009497:0.008651:0.009497:0.006464:0.007374:0.009002:0.009034:0.006416:0.009034:0.003655:0.005411:0.008108:0.009401:0.005890:0.008124:0.009385:0.009545:0.009034:0.005411:0.005299:0.006895:0.006384:0.006767:0.009385:0.008348:0.007087:0.003863:0.004996:0.003863:0.007374:0.005618:0.003607:0.006464:0.006384:0.008651:0.007901:0.003464
Ms Meadows became aware that she might be a carrier :@0.049227:0.203047:0.450854:0.203047:0.450854:0.192462:0.049227:0.192462:0.013359:0.006384:0.006464:0.014540:0.008348:0.008124:0.009401:0.009353:0.011540:0.006767:0.006113:0.009385:0.007996:0.007374:0.007917:0.013742:0.008012:0.006049:0.008124:0.011779:0.008316:0.005554:0.008555:0.005203:0.005411:0.009369:0.008316:0.005411:0.005762:0.006464:0.008571:0.007981:0.006049:0.013742:0.003863:0.009401:0.008779:0.005411:0.005586:0.008571:0.007566:0.006049:0.006799:0.006049:0.007374:0.007837:0.005554:0.005554:0.003671:0.008156:0.005554:0.004373
of the haemophilia gene when  her nephew was born  in :@0.048387:0.218726:0.450764:0.218726:0.450764:0.208141:0.048387:0.208141:0.009353:0.004756:0.005203:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006049:0.009034:0.007853:0.008348:0.013487:0.009353:0.009210:0.009034:0.003863:0.003863:0.003863:0.008124:0.005953:0.009401:0.008076:0.009034:0.008108:0.004868:0.011923:0.009321:0.008571:0.009321:0.004373:0.002426:0.008731:0.008060:0.005379:0.006049:0.009321:0.008348:0.009800:0.009034:0.008603:0.011763:0.004373:0.012178:0.008571:0.007135:0.006049:0.008986:0.008906:0.005299:0.008651:0.004373:0.002522:0.003112:0.007390:0.004373
2006 and diagnosed with  haemophilia. She wished to :@0.048387:0.234107:0.438251:0.234107:0.438251:0.223523:0.048387:0.223523:0.008986:0.009162:0.009066:0.009066:0.005634:0.007805:0.008651:0.008986:0.006384:0.009401:0.003623:0.008124:0.009018:0.009034:0.009034:0.006767:0.008012:0.009401:0.005475:0.011763:0.003863:0.005714:0.009321:0.004373:0.002426:0.009034:0.007933:0.008348:0.013742:0.009353:0.009385:0.009034:0.003863:0.003863:0.003863:0.008124:0.003464:0.006767:0.008236:0.008731:0.008060:0.004788:0.011540:0.004086:0.006767:0.009034:0.008651:0.009577:0.006049:0.005123:0.008986:0.004373
avoid  having a child with the condition and so consulted :@0.048387:0.249489:0.455265:0.249489:0.455265:0.238905:0.048387:0.238905:0.007805:0.007310:0.008906:0.003863:0.008826:0.004373:0.002426:0.008731:0.007805:0.007390:0.003863:0.008731:0.009066:0.006049:0.006799:0.006464:0.006975:0.008571:0.003863:0.003527:0.008906:0.005714:0.011843:0.003863:0.005634:0.009241:0.006049:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005634:0.007374:0.009178:0.009034:0.009194:0.003863:0.005203:0.003863:0.009082:0.009034:0.006416:0.007805:0.008571:0.008986:0.006049:0.006464:0.008826:0.005299:0.007374:0.009002:0.009034:0.006416:0.009034:0.003655:0.005411:0.008108:0.009401:0.004373
her GP. The GP,  Dr Khan, arranged blood tests to establish :@0.048807:0.264929:0.465677:0.264929:0.465677:0.254345:0.048807:0.254345:0.008731:0.008060:0.005379:0.006049:0.009241:0.007566:0.002937:0.006464:0.008364:0.008779:0.008348:0.006352:0.009497:0.007725:0.002937:0.004373:0.002522:0.010502:0.005203:0.006464:0.009257:0.009225:0.008124:0.009034:0.003464:0.006432:0.008124:0.005554:0.005554:0.007821:0.009034:0.009401:0.008108:0.009401:0.006736:0.008906:0.003863:0.008651:0.008826:0.008906:0.005634:0.005411:0.008108:0.006767:0.005411:0.006560:0.005299:0.005411:0.009034:0.005299:0.008060:0.006560:0.005203:0.007901:0.009066:0.003863:0.003863:0.006305:0.008826:0.004373
whether she had haemophilia -  the results were normal. :@0.047547:0.280311:0.453994:0.280311:0.453994:0.269727:0.047547:0.269727:0.012019:0.009497:0.008651:0.005714:0.009401:0.008651:0.005794:0.005634:0.006464:0.008571:0.007981:0.006384:0.008491:0.007645:0.008906:0.006464:0.009034:0.007773:0.008348:0.013487:0.009353:0.009210:0.009034:0.003863:0.003863:0.003863:0.008124:0.005523:0.006384:0.002522:0.004373:0.005411:0.009034:0.008348:0.005938:0.005379:0.008060:0.006560:0.008826:0.003863:0.005123:0.006560:0.004788:0.011763:0.008651:0.005554:0.008731:0.006464:0.008826:0.009162:0.005554:0.013423:0.007901:0.003863:0.003272:0.004373
However, the GP failed to advise her that these tests :@0.049227:0.295693:0.425301:0.295693:0.425301:0.285109:0.049227:0.285109:0.010997:0.009162:0.011348:0.008156:0.007470:0.008156:0.005554:0.003272:0.006049:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006049:0.010662:0.008651:0.005203:0.004996:0.007949:0.003863:0.003863:0.008060:0.009401:0.005890:0.005123:0.008986:0.005634:0.007805:0.009162:0.007390:0.003863:0.006464:0.008060:0.006384:0.008731:0.008060:0.005379:0.004868:0.005411:0.009369:0.008316:0.005411:0.004916:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006767:0.008348:0.005459:0.005203:0.008156:0.006560:0.005411:0.006512:0.004373
could  not confirm whether she was a carrier of the gene.:@0.048387:0.311372:0.454914:0.311372:0.454914:0.300788:0.048387:0.300788:0.007135:0.008906:0.008731:0.003863:0.008826:0.004373:0.002522:0.008826:0.008986:0.005203:0.005634:0.007374:0.009178:0.009034:0.004996:0.003863:0.005554:0.013742:0.005155:0.011923:0.009497:0.008651:0.005714:0.009401:0.008651:0.005794:0.005634:0.006464:0.008571:0.007981:0.004788:0.012354:0.008651:0.007230:0.005299:0.006799:0.006464:0.007374:0.008124:0.005331:0.005554:0.003863:0.008348:0.005331:0.005714:0.009353:0.004756:0.004788:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006049:0.009162:0.008060:0.008826:0.008060:0.003464
Thinking that all was well,  Ms Meadows became :@0.047967:0.333347:0.399572:0.333347:0.399572:0.322763:0.047967:0.322763:0.008364:0.009034:0.003863:0.009034:0.007933:0.003863:0.009034:0.009401:0.006001:0.005411:0.009034:0.008316:0.005411:0.005682:0.007230:0.003448:0.003448:0.005714:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.004788:0.012178:0.008826:0.004038:0.004038:0.003464:0.004373:0.003080:0.013359:0.006384:0.006464:0.014540:0.008348:0.008124:0.009401:0.009353:0.011540:0.006767:0.006113:0.009162:0.008156:0.007374:0.007741:0.013439:0.008156:0.004373
pregnant in 2010.  Her son developed severe haemophilia. :@0.048807:0.349026:0.464033:0.349026:0.464033:0.338442:0.048807:0.338442:0.009385:0.005554:0.008156:0.009401:0.009034:0.008124:0.009034:0.005411:0.005618:0.003272:0.007645:0.006464:0.009066:0.009162:0.008986:0.009066:0.003464:0.004373:0.003416:0.010502:0.007725:0.005123:0.005714:0.006305:0.008651:0.008395:0.006464:0.009401:0.007901:0.007470:0.008156:0.003863:0.008986:0.009162:0.008060:0.009162:0.006464:0.006560:0.007981:0.007310:0.007981:0.005299:0.007981:0.006049:0.009034:0.008124:0.008348:0.013471:0.009353:0.009210:0.009034:0.003863:0.003863:0.003863:0.007933:0.003464:0.004373
She claimed that had she been given correct advice, :@0.048387:0.364407:0.421652:0.364407:0.421652:0.353822:0.048387:0.353822:0.008236:0.008731:0.008060:0.006049:0.007374:0.003623:0.007805:0.003863:0.013280:0.008060:0.009162:0.006049:0.005411:0.009369:0.008316:0.005411:0.005762:0.008491:0.007645:0.008906:0.006464:0.006464:0.008571:0.007901:0.006464:0.008906:0.007805:0.007805:0.008571:0.006384:0.008986:0.003863:0.007135:0.007981:0.008731:0.006464:0.007374:0.009353:0.005363:0.005554:0.008348:0.007103:0.005411:0.005092:0.008124:0.009098:0.007470:0.003863:0.007055:0.008348:0.003240:0.004373
she would  have chosen a termination. As well as :@0.048387:0.379787:0.399913:0.379787:0.399913:0.369203:0.048387:0.369203:0.006464:0.008571:0.007981:0.005203:0.011540:0.009720:0.009034:0.004070:0.009577:0.004373:0.002522:0.008731:0.007725:0.007390:0.007981:0.006049:0.007135:0.008731:0.009066:0.006464:0.008156:0.008826:0.006464:0.006799:0.006049:0.005411:0.008539:0.005554:0.013742:0.003863:0.009273:0.008124:0.005411:0.003863:0.009561:0.009034:0.003464:0.006145:0.010662:0.007055:0.004373:0.011843:0.008571:0.003863:0.004038:0.006464:0.007470:0.006209:0.004373
haemophilia,  her son has the unrelated condition :@0.048807:0.395169:0.402392:0.395169:0.402392:0.384585:0.048807:0.384585:0.009034:0.008124:0.008555:0.013742:0.009353:0.009385:0.009034:0.003863:0.003863:0.003863:0.008124:0.003464:0.004373:0.002426:0.008731:0.008060:0.005379:0.005203:0.006384:0.008826:0.008571:0.006464:0.008731:0.007725:0.006560:0.005203:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006464:0.008826:0.008731:0.005554:0.008060:0.003863:0.007901:0.005411:0.008108:0.009401:0.006305:0.007374:0.008922:0.008826:0.009162:0.003863:0.005123:0.003863:0.008986:0.008826:0.004373
of autism.  Dr Khan admitted  liability for the losses :@0.048387:0.410611:0.409202:0.410611:0.409202:0.400026:0.048387:0.400026:0.009353:0.004756:0.005634:0.008124:0.008842:0.005411:0.003863:0.006767:0.013535:0.003464:0.004373:0.002921:0.010502:0.005203:0.006049:0.009257:0.009034:0.007837:0.009034:0.006001:0.008124:0.009178:0.013519:0.003863:0.005411:0.005171:0.008348:0.009210:0.004373:0.002522:0.003863:0.003527:0.007901:0.008986:0.003863:0.003863:0.003623:0.005411:0.007358:0.004868:0.004996:0.009545:0.005554:0.004868:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006464:0.003863:0.008651:0.006384:0.006384:0.007805:0.006384:0.004373
arising from haemophilia but not those resulting from :@0.048387:0.426052:0.435394:0.426052:0.435394:0.415467:0.048387:0.415467:0.007805:0.005299:0.003863:0.006464:0.003863:0.008731:0.009162:0.005634:0.004996:0.005554:0.009353:0.013535:0.006464:0.009034:0.007773:0.008348:0.013487:0.009353:0.009210:0.009034:0.003863:0.003863:0.003863:0.008124:0.006368:0.009066:0.008731:0.005203:0.006049:0.008731:0.008986:0.005203:0.005299:0.005411:0.008779:0.009162:0.006767:0.008348:0.006305:0.005299:0.007981:0.006560:0.008731:0.003863:0.004964:0.003863:0.008571:0.008986:0.006049:0.004788:0.005554:0.008986:0.013359:0.004373
autism, which in monetary terms were much  higher.:@0.048387:0.441670:0.419545:0.441670:0.419545:0.431086:0.048387:0.431086:0.008124:0.009034:0.005411:0.003863:0.006767:0.013742:0.003464:0.005634:0.011843:0.009401:0.004038:0.007645:0.009401:0.006464:0.003368:0.007901:0.006464:0.013742:0.009353:0.009034:0.008348:0.005411:0.008124:0.005554:0.007725:0.004868:0.005411:0.008348:0.005554:0.013535:0.006767:0.004740:0.011763:0.008651:0.005554:0.008731:0.006464:0.013359:0.008651:0.007135:0.008731:0.004373:0.002522:0.008571:0.003607:0.008826:0.008571:0.007901:0.005203:0.003464
The Supreme Court had to decide whether Dr Khan :@0.047967:0.463588:0.420880:0.463588:0.420880:0.453004:0.047967:0.453004:0.008364:0.008858:0.008348:0.005938:0.008475:0.008667:0.009385:0.005315:0.008348:0.013327:0.008156:0.006049:0.010167:0.009577:0.009241:0.005794:0.005411:0.005762:0.008491:0.007645:0.008906:0.006049:0.005411:0.009130:0.005634:0.009066:0.008156:0.007374:0.003623:0.009162:0.008156:0.004868:0.011923:0.009497:0.008651:0.005714:0.009401:0.008651:0.005794:0.006049:0.010247:0.005123:0.006384:0.008986:0.008731:0.007805:0.008731:0.004373
was responsible for the financial consequences of :@0.047547:0.479030:0.406048:0.479030:0.406048:0.468445:0.047547:0.468445:0.012178:0.008571:0.007135:0.006049:0.005379:0.008156:0.006767:0.009018:0.009066:0.008826:0.006560:0.003863:0.009082:0.003863:0.008060:0.005203:0.004996:0.009545:0.005554:0.005283:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005299:0.004996:0.003863:0.009210:0.008124:0.009034:0.007374:0.003863:0.008124:0.003863:0.006416:0.007374:0.009178:0.009034:0.006592:0.008348:0.009401:0.009034:0.008348:0.009034:0.007374:0.008348:0.006767:0.005682:0.008906:0.004788:0.004373
the autism.  Using the example of a commercial case :@0.047967:0.494707:0.423354:0.494707:0.423354:0.484123:0.047967:0.484123:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006049:0.008124:0.008842:0.005411:0.003863:0.006767:0.013535:0.003464:0.004373:0.002921:0.010423:0.006384:0.003607:0.008571:0.008906:0.006049:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005634:0.008348:0.007326:0.007933:0.013742:0.009385:0.003863:0.008348:0.005570:0.009353:0.004756:0.005634:0.006895:0.006049:0.007374:0.009098:0.013742:0.013391:0.008348:0.005554:0.007182:0.003863:0.007901:0.003863:0.006384:0.006975:0.007645:0.006464:0.007901:0.004373
decided  by the House of Lords in  1997, a  key question :@0.048387:0.510089:0.440677:0.510089:0.440677:0.499505:0.048387:0.499505:0.009066:0.008060:0.007135:0.003863:0.009082:0.008060:0.009162:0.004373:0.002522:0.008651:0.007055:0.004788:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006464:0.010997:0.008986:0.008731:0.006464:0.007981:0.005634:0.009353:0.004756:0.006049:0.007135:0.008906:0.005299:0.008906:0.006464:0.005634:0.003368:0.007901:0.004373:0.003272:0.008826:0.008826:0.008603:0.008954:0.003464:0.006528:0.006895:0.004373:0.002426:0.007566:0.008060:0.007390:0.005203:0.009401:0.008571:0.008348:0.006432:0.005411:0.003655:0.009066:0.008826:0.004373
was  \what:@0.047547:0.525471:0.412512:0.525471:0.412512:0.514887:0.047547:0.514887:0.012178:0.008571:0.007135:0.004373:0.002426:0.006720:0.012593:0.009752:0.008906:0.005874:0.003783:0.004373:0.002426:0.003527:0.004533:0.005299:0.007725:0.008395:0.007230:0.003192:0.004373:0.002522:0.005299:0.003863:0.006305:0.007470:0.006464:0.005714:0.009353:0.004756:0.006049:0.009034:0.007677:0.005379:0.013359:0.006049:0.008491:0.003527:0.008571:0.006049:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006049:0.009401:0.008348:0.004996:0.008348:0.009321:0.009401:0.008124:0.009273:0.005411:0.004373
owe a duty of care to protect the claimant against?\:@0.048387:0.540852:0.422114:0.540852:0.422114:0.530267:0.048387:0.530267:0.009353:0.011987:0.008348:0.005762:0.006895:0.006464:0.009401:0.008667:0.005411:0.007534:0.005299:0.009353:0.004756:0.005203:0.007374:0.007741:0.005379:0.008156:0.005203:0.005411:0.009130:0.006049:0.009385:0.005315:0.009162:0.005411:0.008108:0.007374:0.005219:0.004868:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006049:0.007374:0.004054:0.008124:0.003863:0.013742:0.008124:0.009034:0.005411:0.005554:0.008316:0.009752:0.008316:0.004038:0.009401:0.006975:0.005634:0.007390:0.006257
This was important because the law does not impose :@0.047967:0.556236:0.431383:0.556236:0.431383:0.545652:0.047967:0.545652:0.008364:0.008683:0.003863:0.006560:0.004788:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.006049:0.003863:0.013742:0.009385:0.009353:0.005554:0.005411:0.008124:0.009034:0.005411:0.005985:0.009162:0.008156:0.007374:0.007741:0.008826:0.006767:0.008012:0.005634:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006049:0.003863:0.008491:0.011843:0.005203:0.009162:0.009066:0.008348:0.006528:0.005634:0.009034:0.009114:0.005411:0.005507:0.003863:0.013184:0.008986:0.009066:0.006464:0.007981:0.004373
responsibility on a defendant for everything which follows :@0.048807:0.571677:0.466507:0.571677:0.466507:0.561093:0.048807:0.561093:0.005379:0.008060:0.006767:0.009114:0.009162:0.009034:0.006416:0.003863:0.009162:0.003863:0.003863:0.003623:0.005411:0.007438:0.005203:0.008571:0.008395:0.006384:0.006895:0.006049:0.009577:0.008348:0.005267:0.008348:0.009210:0.009401:0.008124:0.009273:0.005411:0.005251:0.004996:0.009545:0.005554:0.005363:0.008156:0.007470:0.008348:0.005347:0.007725:0.005123:0.009034:0.003655:0.008826:0.009401:0.005554:0.011843:0.009401:0.004038:0.007645:0.009401:0.005634:0.004996:0.009353:0.004054:0.003863:0.009577:0.011540:0.007023:0.004373
from  his or her act or omission,  even if it is wrongful.:@0.047967:0.587355:0.424855:0.587355:0.424855:0.576770:0.047967:0.576770:0.004996:0.005554:0.009018:0.013519:0.004373:0.002426:0.008395:0.003527:0.006209:0.005714:0.008826:0.005299:0.005634:0.008731:0.008060:0.005379:0.005634:0.008124:0.007166:0.005411:0.005507:0.008826:0.005299:0.005203:0.009353:0.013503:0.003863:0.006767:0.006512:0.003863:0.009353:0.008795:0.003464:0.004373:0.002410:0.007901:0.007310:0.007981:0.008651:0.006464:0.003863:0.004533:0.005714:0.003368:0.004709:0.006049:0.003192:0.005634:0.004868:0.011763:0.005554:0.009816:0.009034:0.009784:0.004996:0.009289:0.003863:0.003464
In this case the patient approached  her GP surgery :@0.048807:0.609271:0.412814:0.609271:0.412814:0.598686:0.048807:0.598686:0.003448:0.007390:0.006049:0.005411:0.008779:0.003863:0.006560:0.005634:0.007374:0.007741:0.006767:0.008012:0.005203:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006464:0.009385:0.008124:0.005411:0.003863:0.008076:0.009034:0.005411:0.005123:0.008124:0.009018:0.009385:0.005315:0.009353:0.007949:0.007374:0.008842:0.008348:0.009401:0.004373:0.002410:0.008731:0.008060:0.005379:0.005634:0.010662:0.008731:0.005634:0.006560:0.008826:0.005554:0.009066:0.008156:0.005554:0.007470:0.004373
specifically to know if she was a carrier of the :@0.048387:0.624950:0.376929:0.624950:0.376929:0.614365:0.048387:0.614365:0.006767:0.009385:0.008348:0.007087:0.003863:0.004996:0.003863:0.007374:0.008124:0.003863:0.003863:0.007486:0.004788:0.005411:0.009130:0.006049:0.008156:0.009401:0.009656:0.011923:0.005634:0.003527:0.004533:0.005634:0.006464:0.008571:0.007981:0.004788:0.012354:0.008651:0.007230:0.005299:0.006799:0.006464:0.007374:0.008124:0.005331:0.005554:0.003863:0.008348:0.005331:0.005714:0.009353:0.004756:0.004788:0.005411:0.008699:0.008060:0.004373
haemophilia gene. Although there was a causal  link :@0.048807:0.640330:0.422119:0.640330:0.422119:0.629746:0.048807:0.629746:0.009034:0.007773:0.008348:0.013487:0.009353:0.009210:0.009034:0.003863:0.003863:0.003863:0.008124:0.005953:0.009401:0.008076:0.009034:0.008012:0.003464:0.005938:0.010295:0.004070:0.005411:0.009210:0.009577:0.009034:0.009704:0.009241:0.006049:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005554:0.008140:0.004868:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.005634:0.006895:0.006464:0.007135:0.007805:0.008826:0.006560:0.007805:0.003863:0.004373:0.002426:0.003863:0.003607:0.008731:0.007566:0.004373
between the admitted  negligence of Dr Khan and :@0.048807:0.655711:0.407196:0.655711:0.407196:0.645126:0.048807:0.645126:0.009385:0.008348:0.005411:0.011540:0.008348:0.008348:0.009034:0.006113:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005634:0.008124:0.009401:0.013391:0.003863:0.005411:0.005171:0.008348:0.009210:0.004373:0.002426:0.009034:0.008348:0.009082:0.003863:0.003863:0.009082:0.008348:0.008795:0.007374:0.008076:0.005634:0.009353:0.004756:0.006049:0.010502:0.005203:0.006049:0.009257:0.009034:0.007837:0.009034:0.006001:0.007645:0.008491:0.008826:0.004373
the birth of the child, that was not relevant to the :@0.047967:0.671152:0.407617:0.671152:0.407617:0.660568:0.047967:0.660568:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006464:0.008986:0.003607:0.005203:0.005044:0.008571:0.006049:0.009353:0.005187:0.004868:0.005411:0.009034:0.008076:0.006049:0.007374:0.008763:0.003863:0.003863:0.009082:0.003464:0.005938:0.005411:0.009369:0.008316:0.005411:0.004581:0.012354:0.008651:0.007230:0.005634:0.009034:0.009114:0.005411:0.005507:0.005554:0.008140:0.003863:0.008348:0.007454:0.008124:0.008842:0.005411:0.004756:0.005411:0.009130:0.005203:0.005411:0.008699:0.008060:0.004373
scope of his duty. The law did  not impose on  Dr Khan :@0.048387:0.686533:0.434612:0.686533:0.434612:0.675948:0.048387:0.675948:0.006560:0.007055:0.009162:0.009066:0.008060:0.006049:0.009353:0.004756:0.005634:0.008571:0.003607:0.006384:0.005299:0.008731:0.008395:0.005044:0.007230:0.003192:0.006464:0.008364:0.008858:0.008348:0.006273:0.003863:0.008491:0.011843:0.005299:0.008491:0.003527:0.008571:0.004373:0.002426:0.008826:0.008986:0.005203:0.006049:0.003863:0.013184:0.008986:0.009066:0.006464:0.007981:0.006049:0.008571:0.008395:0.004373:0.002426:0.010582:0.005203:0.006049:0.008986:0.008731:0.007805:0.008731:0.004373
any duty in relation to unrelated risks that might :@0.048387:0.701914:0.397662:0.701914:0.397662:0.691329:0.048387:0.691329:0.008124:0.008842:0.007725:0.005123:0.009401:0.008667:0.005411:0.007725:0.005507:0.003368:0.007901:0.006464:0.005299:0.008060:0.003863:0.007821:0.005203:0.003863:0.009082:0.008826:0.006049:0.005123:0.008986:0.006049:0.008826:0.008826:0.005554:0.008060:0.003863:0.007901:0.005411:0.008108:0.009401:0.006640:0.005299:0.003863:0.006305:0.007566:0.006464:0.005203:0.005411:0.009369:0.008316:0.005411:0.005762:0.013742:0.003639:0.009401:0.008667:0.005411:0.004373
arise in  pregnancy.  It followed that he was liable :@0.048387:0.717592:0.395874:0.717592:0.395874:0.707008:0.048387:0.707008:0.007901:0.005379:0.003863:0.006305:0.007981:0.006464:0.003272:0.007645:0.004373:0.002426:0.008986:0.005379:0.007981:0.009066:0.008731:0.007805:0.008731:0.007055:0.007470:0.003464:0.004373:0.002825:0.003783:0.004709:0.004788:0.004996:0.009624:0.003863:0.003863:0.009353:0.011540:0.008603:0.009401:0.006145:0.005411:0.009369:0.008316:0.005411:0.005762:0.008395:0.007725:0.005203:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.006049:0.003607:0.003863:0.007566:0.008906:0.003863:0.007725:0.004373
only for the costs associated with  haemophilia.:@0.048387:0.732973:0.381111:0.732973:0.381111:0.722389:0.048387:0.722389:0.009162:0.009034:0.003655:0.007725:0.004709:0.004996:0.009545:0.005554:0.004948:0.005411:0.009034:0.008076:0.006049:0.007055:0.008986:0.006560:0.005123:0.006560:0.005714:0.008124:0.006496:0.006767:0.009114:0.007374:0.003623:0.008124:0.005155:0.008156:0.009401:0.005475:0.011763:0.003863:0.005714:0.009321:0.004373:0.002426:0.009034:0.008124:0.008348:0.013471:0.009353:0.009210:0.009034:0.003863:0.003863:0.003863:0.007933:0.003464
Comment:@0.048387:0.755672:0.124311:0.755672:0.124311:0.744530:0.048387:0.744530:0.010484:0.009845:0.015037:0.015037:0.009089:0.009896:0.006536
This is a very important ruling from the Supreme :@0.047967:0.777165:0.397130:0.777165:0.397130:0.766580:0.047967:0.766580:0.008364:0.008683:0.003863:0.006560:0.006049:0.003192:0.005634:0.005634:0.006895:0.005634:0.007645:0.008348:0.005554:0.007518:0.005634:0.003863:0.013742:0.009385:0.009353:0.005554:0.005411:0.008124:0.009034:0.005411:0.005554:0.005299:0.008731:0.003863:0.003527:0.008651:0.008986:0.006049:0.004996:0.005554:0.009018:0.013519:0.005634:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006049:0.008475:0.008667:0.009385:0.005315:0.008348:0.013327:0.008156:0.004373
Court. Those acting for the mother argued that if it :@0.048387:0.792606:0.419305:0.792606:0.419305:0.782022:0.048387:0.782022:0.010167:0.009353:0.009289:0.005554:0.005618:0.003464:0.006528:0.008364:0.009034:0.009146:0.006767:0.008348:0.005554:0.008124:0.006991:0.005411:0.003863:0.008699:0.009401:0.005475:0.004996:0.009545:0.005554:0.005283:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006049:0.013742:0.009353:0.005219:0.009034:0.008348:0.005554:0.005203:0.007901:0.005554:0.009146:0.008826:0.008156:0.009401:0.005890:0.005411:0.009369:0.008316:0.005411:0.005762:0.003863:0.004629:0.005634:0.003192:0.004453:0.004373
wasn't for the doctor's negligence,  her child would :@0.047547:0.808284:0.414347:0.808284:0.414347:0.797699:0.047547:0.797699:0.012354:0.008731:0.007310:0.009577:0.003942:0.005714:0.004788:0.004996:0.009545:0.005554:0.005363:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005634:0.009066:0.009066:0.007135:0.005203:0.009162:0.005379:0.003671:0.006496:0.005714:0.009034:0.008348:0.009162:0.003863:0.003863:0.009401:0.008348:0.009034:0.007374:0.008348:0.003464:0.004373:0.002410:0.008731:0.008060:0.005379:0.005299:0.006975:0.008571:0.003863:0.003527:0.008906:0.005634:0.011540:0.009624:0.009034:0.003863:0.009401:0.004373
not have been born and therefore the defendant :@0.048807:0.823664:0.401562:0.823664:0.401562:0.813080:0.048807:0.813080:0.008731:0.008986:0.005203:0.006049:0.008731:0.007805:0.007390:0.007981:0.006384:0.008906:0.007981:0.007981:0.008651:0.006464:0.008986:0.008906:0.005299:0.008651:0.006464:0.007805:0.008571:0.008986:0.006049:0.005411:0.009034:0.008348:0.005554:0.008348:0.004996:0.009353:0.005554:0.008348:0.005203:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006049:0.009401:0.008348:0.004996:0.008348:0.009321:0.009401:0.008124:0.009273:0.005411:0.004373
should  be responsible for the financial consequences :@0.048387:0.839045:0.428690:0.839045:0.428690:0.828461:0.048387:0.828461:0.006560:0.008731:0.008986:0.008826:0.003863:0.008986:0.004373:0.002522:0.008571:0.007566:0.006049:0.005379:0.008156:0.006767:0.009018:0.009066:0.008826:0.006560:0.003863:0.009082:0.003863:0.008060:0.005203:0.004996:0.009545:0.005554:0.005363:0.005411:0.009034:0.008076:0.005299:0.004996:0.003863:0.009210:0.008124:0.009034:0.007374:0.003863:0.008124:0.003863:0.006496:0.007374:0.009178:0.009034:0.006592:0.008348:0.009401:0.009034:0.008348:0.009034:0.007374:0.008348:0.006767:0.004373
of all  his disabilities. The Court ruled that this was the :@0.048387:0.854426:0.435011:0.854426:0.435011:0.843841:0.048387:0.843841:0.009353:0.004756:0.005634:0.007230:0.003448:0.003448:0.004373:0.002522:0.008395:0.003527:0.006209:0.005634:0.009162:0.003863:0.006560:0.007901:0.009162:0.003863:0.003863:0.003623:0.005203:0.003863:0.008060:0.006560:0.003464:0.006704:0.008364:0.008858:0.008348:0.005507:0.010167:0.009577:0.009241:0.005794:0.005411:0.005762:0.005379:0.008651:0.003863:0.007821:0.008986:0.005634:0.005411:0.009369:0.008316:0.005411:0.005347:0.005411:0.008779:0.003863:0.006560:0.004868:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.005203:0.005411:0.008699:0.008060:0.004373
wrong way to look at the situation. The GP had  not :@0.047547:0.869808:0.420923:0.869808:0.420923:0.859223:0.047547:0.859223:0.011540:0.005762:0.009577:0.009034:0.009704:0.005634:0.012178:0.008651:0.008236:0.004788:0.005411:0.009130:0.006049:0.003863:0.008826:0.009066:0.007645:0.005714:0.008124:0.005155:0.004868:0.005411:0.009034:0.008076:0.005714:0.006767:0.003863:0.005411:0.009034:0.007933:0.005411:0.003863:0.009353:0.009034:0.003464:0.006432:0.008364:0.008779:0.008348:0.006352:0.010662:0.008651:0.005634:0.008491:0.007645:0.008906:0.004373:0.002522:0.008571:0.008826:0.005123:0.004373
been consulted about autism, which  is a risk resulting :@0.048807:0.885249:0.434250:0.885249:0.434250:0.874664:0.048807:0.874664:0.008986:0.007901:0.007901:0.008651:0.006464:0.007374:0.009002:0.009034:0.006512:0.009034:0.003655:0.005411:0.008108:0.009401:0.006225:0.008124:0.009385:0.009353:0.009034:0.005411:0.005060:0.008124:0.009034:0.005411:0.003863:0.006767:0.013742:0.003464:0.006049:0.011843:0.009321:0.003863:0.007645:0.009321:0.004373:0.002426:0.003192:0.005714:0.005634:0.006895:0.006384:0.005299:0.003863:0.006305:0.007566:0.006049:0.005299:0.007981:0.006560:0.008731:0.003863:0.004964:0.003863:0.008571:0.009066:0.004373
from any pregnancy. Consequently, he did  not owe :@0.047967:0.900926:0.417034:0.900926:0.417034:0.890342:0.047967:0.890342:0.004996:0.005554:0.009018:0.013519:0.006464:0.008124:0.008763:0.007725:0.005634:0.008986:0.005379:0.007981:0.009066:0.008731:0.007805:0.008731:0.007055:0.007470:0.003464:0.006704:0.009880:0.009353:0.009034:0.006767:0.008348:0.009401:0.009034:0.008348:0.009034:0.005411:0.003863:0.007725:0.003464:0.006767:0.008395:0.007725:0.005714:0.008731:0.003527:0.008651:0.004373:0.002522:0.008731:0.008986:0.005203:0.005299:0.009353:0.011540:0.008348:0.004373
a duty of care in that regard.  It is a principle which :@0.048387:0.916307:0.411213:0.916307:0.411213:0.905723:0.048387:0.905723:0.006895:0.006384:0.009401:0.008667:0.005411:0.007725:0.005092:0.009353:0.004756:0.005299:0.007374:0.007741:0.005379:0.008156:0.006049:0.003368:0.007901:0.005634:0.005411:0.009369:0.008316:0.005411:0.006177:0.005379:0.007981:0.009066:0.007805:0.005379:0.009066:0.003272:0.004373:0.002937:0.003607:0.004453:0.006049:0.003192:0.005634:0.005634:0.006895:0.006464:0.009385:0.005235:0.003863:0.008651:0.007374:0.003623:0.009162:0.003863:0.008060:0.004868:0.011763:0.009321:0.003863:0.007645:0.009321:0.004373
can  be applied to other clinical  negligence cases.:@0.048387:0.931688:0.394246:0.931688:0.394246:0.921103:0.048387:0.921103:0.007055:0.007645:0.008651:0.004373:0.002522:0.008571:0.007566:0.006049:0.007901:0.008986:0.009066:0.003863:0.003527:0.007981:0.009066:0.006049:0.005411:0.009130:0.005634:0.009353:0.005411:0.008842:0.008348:0.005554:0.005251:0.007055:0.003863:0.003863:0.008571:0.003863:0.007055:0.007901:0.003863:0.004373:0.002426:0.009034:0.008348:0.009162:0.003863:0.003863:0.009082:0.008156:0.009034:0.007103:0.008156:0.005634:0.007055:0.007805:0.006767:0.007933:0.006767:0.003464
Walsh (deceased) v.  Northumbria  Healthcare:@0.488306:0.103397:0.871556:0.103397:0.871556:0.092256:0.488306:0.092256:0.018061:0.009745:0.005040:0.007897:0.010837:0.006888:0.006636:0.011173:0.009745:0.008653:0.009745:0.009745:0.007897:0.009745:0.011173:0.006636:0.006048:0.008317:0.004116:0.004637:0.003091:0.014029:0.010921:0.007140:0.006972:0.010753:0.010837:0.016381:0.011089:0.007140:0.005124:0.009661:0.004637:0.002587:0.013609:0.009661:0.009661:0.005124:0.006972:0.010753:0.008569:0.009661:0.007056:0.009089
 :@0.872127:0.103397:0.876731:0.103397:0.876731:0.092256:0.872127:0.092256:0.004603
NHS Foundation Trust (Newcastle County:@0.489483:0.118779:0.844792:0.118779:0.844792:0.107637:0.489483:0.107637:0.013105:0.012685:0.009425:0.007124:0.009325:0.011005:0.010921:0.010921:0.011173:0.009745:0.007056:0.005040:0.011089:0.010921:0.006468:0.010165:0.006888:0.010501:0.007644:0.006720:0.006048:0.006720:0.014449:0.009829:0.014617:0.008737:0.009745:0.008065:0.007140:0.005208:0.009829:0.006468:0.011341:0.011089:0.011005:0.011005:0.007056:0.009039
 :@0.845581:0.118779:0.850185:0.118779:0.850185:0.107637:0.845581:0.107637:0.004603
Court, 19  May 2021  -  Judge Freedman):@0.489483:0.134457:0.823387:0.134457:0.823387:0.123315:0.489483:0.123315:0.011089:0.010921:0.010837:0.007140:0.006888:0.004788:0.006804:0.009241:0.009325:0.004637:0.002587:0.017221:0.009745:0.009745:0.005628:0.009493:0.009493:0.009661:0.009325:0.004637:0.003007:0.006788:0.002873:0.005208:0.007981:0.010837:0.011173:0.011173:0.009661:0.006888:0.009157:0.007056:0.009577:0.009577:0.011005:0.016213:0.009577:0.010753:0.006200
In 2017  Mr Walsh took his own life by running :@0.489499:0.155179:0.825814:0.155179:0.825814:0.144594:0.489499:0.144594:0.003527:0.007390:0.006464:0.008906:0.008906:0.008826:0.008826:0.004373:0.002857:0.013695:0.005299:0.004373:0.014908:0.007933:0.003863:0.006767:0.009034:0.005953:0.005411:0.009353:0.009353:0.008140:0.006049:0.008395:0.003527:0.006209:0.005634:0.009353:0.011731:0.009034:0.006592:0.003863:0.003527:0.004788:0.007981:0.006049:0.008651:0.007055:0.005634:0.005299:0.009034:0.008699:0.009034:0.003655:0.008826:0.009162:0.004373
onto a major road into the path of oncoming :@0.489079:0.169729:0.815019:0.169729:0.815019:0.159145:0.489079:0.159145:0.009162:0.009034:0.005411:0.009082:0.005634:0.006895:0.006464:0.013519:0.007901:0.003863:0.009162:0.005554:0.005538:0.005203:0.008826:0.007725:0.008906:0.006464:0.003863:0.008826:0.005203:0.009066:0.004868:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006464:0.008986:0.007725:0.005203:0.008651:0.006049:0.009353:0.005187:0.005299:0.009066:0.009034:0.007103:0.009162:0.013519:0.003863:0.008731:0.009401:0.004373
traffic.  It was alleged that security staff had  been :@0.488743:0.184220:0.840636:0.184220:0.840636:0.173636:0.488743:0.173636:0.005411:0.005554:0.008124:0.005267:0.004996:0.003863:0.007613:0.003464:0.004373:0.002921:0.003607:0.004453:0.004868:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.005634:0.007901:0.003863:0.003527:0.008060:0.009066:0.008060:0.009066:0.006049:0.005411:0.009369:0.008316:0.005411:0.005427:0.006767:0.008348:0.007374:0.008763:0.005554:0.003863:0.005411:0.007518:0.005203:0.006767:0.005586:0.008124:0.004996:0.005187:0.005634:0.008491:0.007645:0.008906:0.004373:0.002522:0.008826:0.007805:0.007805:0.008571:0.004373
negligent and that this led to his death.:@0.489499:0.198771:0.769583:0.198771:0.769583:0.188186:0.489499:0.188186:0.009034:0.008348:0.009082:0.003863:0.003863:0.009082:0.008348:0.009034:0.005139:0.005634:0.007805:0.008571:0.008986:0.006049:0.005411:0.009369:0.008316:0.005411:0.005012:0.005411:0.008699:0.003863:0.006560:0.006049:0.003448:0.007470:0.008491:0.006049:0.005411:0.009130:0.006049:0.008395:0.003527:0.006209:0.005634:0.009401:0.008076:0.008124:0.005235:0.009034:0.003464
Mr Walsh had  no history of psychiatric illness, but on :@0.489919:0.220151:0.869712:0.220151:0.869712:0.209566:0.489919:0.209566:0.013695:0.005299:0.004373:0.014700:0.008124:0.003863:0.006767:0.009034:0.006736:0.008491:0.007645:0.008906:0.004373:0.002426:0.008571:0.008826:0.006049:0.008826:0.003863:0.006464:0.005411:0.008954:0.005379:0.007470:0.005203:0.009353:0.004756:0.006049:0.009385:0.006576:0.007725:0.007374:0.008842:0.003863:0.008124:0.005235:0.005554:0.003863:0.007374:0.005554:0.003863:0.003607:0.003863:0.008571:0.008060:0.006560:0.006464:0.003464:0.006704:0.009066:0.008731:0.005203:0.005634:0.008395:0.008156:0.004373
23 January 2017  he had struck one of his children and :@0.489079:0.234701:0.881417:0.234701:0.881417:0.224117:0.489079:0.224117:0.008603:0.008364:0.005634:0.005698:0.008124:0.009369:0.009241:0.008124:0.005554:0.007917:0.005299:0.008986:0.009066:0.008906:0.008906:0.004373:0.002522:0.008395:0.007725:0.006049:0.008571:0.007566:0.008826:0.006464:0.006767:0.005411:0.005554:0.009225:0.007374:0.007933:0.005267:0.008986:0.008826:0.008060:0.006049:0.009353:0.004756:0.005634:0.008571:0.003607:0.006384:0.005634:0.007055:0.008731:0.003863:0.003863:0.008986:0.005379:0.008156:0.008826:0.006384:0.007645:0.008491:0.008906:0.004373
as a  result was required to leave the family home.  He :@0.489079:0.249252:0.870883:0.249252:0.870883:0.238667:0.489079:0.238667:0.007470:0.006305:0.005634:0.006799:0.004373:0.002522:0.005299:0.007981:0.006560:0.008731:0.003863:0.005044:0.004868:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.006049:0.005299:0.007981:0.008986:0.008651:0.003863:0.005123:0.007981:0.008986:0.006049:0.005411:0.009130:0.006049:0.003607:0.007981:0.007805:0.007310:0.007981:0.005203:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005634:0.004996:0.008124:0.014094:0.003863:0.003863:0.007725:0.005714:0.009034:0.009114:0.013519:0.008156:0.003464:0.004373:0.003160:0.009992:0.007310:0.004373
then took an overdose of paracetamol, and did so again :@0.488743:0.263802:0.893483:0.263802:0.893483:0.253218:0.488743:0.253218:0.005203:0.009034:0.008348:0.008826:0.005634:0.005411:0.009353:0.009353:0.008140:0.005634:0.007645:0.008491:0.006049:0.009066:0.007390:0.008348:0.005347:0.009401:0.009002:0.006767:0.008012:0.005634:0.009353:0.004756:0.006049:0.009385:0.008124:0.005762:0.008124:0.007374:0.008348:0.005411:0.008124:0.013742:0.009353:0.003863:0.003464:0.006544:0.007805:0.008571:0.008986:0.006049:0.008651:0.003607:0.008731:0.006464:0.006305:0.008571:0.005634:0.007901:0.009066:0.007725:0.003863:0.008571:0.004373
on 4 February.  He was taken  by ambulance to hospital :@0.489079:0.278292:0.879949:0.278292:0.879949:0.267708:0.489079:0.267708:0.008571:0.008395:0.006049:0.008906:0.005634:0.007470:0.007981:0.008986:0.005299:0.008571:0.007805:0.005299:0.007390:0.003272:0.004373:0.003272:0.010247:0.007470:0.005299:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.005203:0.005411:0.007949:0.007933:0.008348:0.009034:0.004373:0.002570:0.008651:0.007055:0.005203:0.008124:0.013742:0.009385:0.009241:0.003863:0.008124:0.009034:0.007374:0.008571:0.005203:0.005411:0.009130:0.006049:0.008651:0.008906:0.006384:0.008986:0.003863:0.005044:0.007725:0.003863:0.004373
and after initial assessment was sent for a psychiatric :@0.489079:0.292782:0.870548:0.292782:0.870548:0.282197:0.489079:0.282197:0.007805:0.008651:0.008986:0.006049:0.008316:0.004996:0.005586:0.008348:0.005762:0.005714:0.003607:0.008651:0.003863:0.004964:0.003863:0.007645:0.003863:0.006225:0.008124:0.006767:0.006767:0.008156:0.006767:0.006767:0.013519:0.008348:0.009034:0.005219:0.004373:0.012434:0.008651:0.007230:0.005203:0.006767:0.008348:0.009034:0.005411:0.004709:0.004996:0.009545:0.005554:0.005698:0.006895:0.006464:0.009385:0.006496:0.007725:0.007374:0.008763:0.003863:0.007821:0.005411:0.005554:0.003655:0.007374:0.004373
review. An  hour later he told a physician's assistant that :@0.489499:0.307392:0.888541:0.307392:0.888541:0.296807:0.489499:0.296807:0.005299:0.008060:0.007390:0.003863:0.008060:0.011173:0.003464:0.005938:0.010502:0.009241:0.004373:0.002522:0.009034:0.009353:0.008747:0.005554:0.005618:0.003863:0.007821:0.005411:0.008028:0.005554:0.005618:0.008395:0.007725:0.005634:0.005123:0.008906:0.003863:0.008731:0.006384:0.006895:0.006464:0.009066:0.008651:0.007470:0.006767:0.003655:0.007135:0.003863:0.007725:0.008826:0.003671:0.006496:0.005714:0.008124:0.006576:0.006767:0.003863:0.006767:0.005411:0.008124:0.009034:0.005411:0.004772:0.005411:0.009034:0.008316:0.005411:0.004373
because the hospital was not doing anything to help :@0.489499:0.322001:0.868143:0.322001:0.868143:0.311417:0.489499:0.311417:0.009162:0.008156:0.007374:0.007741:0.008826:0.006767:0.008012:0.005714:0.005411:0.009034:0.008076:0.006049:0.008731:0.008986:0.006560:0.009162:0.003863:0.005203:0.007805:0.003863:0.005538:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.006049:0.008826:0.008986:0.005203:0.005634:0.008906:0.008826:0.003863:0.008491:0.008986:0.006464:0.008124:0.008763:0.007725:0.005411:0.008795:0.003863:0.009034:0.009194:0.006049:0.005411:0.009130:0.005634:0.008571:0.007901:0.003863:0.008731:0.004373
him he was going to kill  himself.  He ran towards an area :@0.489499:0.336491:0.895995:0.336491:0.895995:0.325907:0.489499:0.325907:0.008491:0.003607:0.012944:0.006464:0.008571:0.007901:0.004868:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.005634:0.009066:0.008986:0.003863:0.008571:0.009066:0.005634:0.005411:0.009130:0.006049:0.006975:0.003448:0.003448:0.003448:0.004373:0.002522:0.009034:0.003863:0.013487:0.006767:0.008348:0.003863:0.004788:0.003464:0.004373:0.003256:0.010247:0.007566:0.006049:0.005203:0.007645:0.008491:0.005634:0.005411:0.009624:0.011763:0.008316:0.005554:0.009656:0.006975:0.005634:0.007645:0.008491:0.006049:0.007725:0.005299:0.007901:0.007725:0.004373
with easy access to the main  road.  Security officers were :@0.488323:0.350982:0.895090:0.350982:0.895090:0.340398:0.488323:0.340398:0.011763:0.003863:0.005714:0.009321:0.006384:0.008060:0.008124:0.006496:0.007725:0.005123:0.008124:0.007166:0.007374:0.008076:0.006560:0.006767:0.005076:0.005123:0.008986:0.005299:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006384:0.013104:0.007645:0.003863:0.008491:0.004373:0.002522:0.005299:0.008906:0.007805:0.008986:0.003272:0.004373:0.002857:0.008475:0.008348:0.007198:0.009034:0.005554:0.003863:0.005155:0.007725:0.005123:0.009353:0.004996:0.004996:0.003863:0.007374:0.008348:0.005554:0.006767:0.004373:0.011747:0.008651:0.005554:0.008731:0.004373
summoned and were able bring  him back to the building. :@0.489079:0.365830:0.904098:0.365830:0.904098:0.355245:0.489079:0.355245:0.006767:0.008858:0.013742:0.013391:0.009353:0.009034:0.008156:0.009401:0.005969:0.007805:0.008651:0.008986:0.005634:0.011763:0.008651:0.005554:0.008731:0.006049:0.007901:0.008986:0.003863:0.007901:0.006384:0.008906:0.005203:0.003607:0.008491:0.008906:0.004373:0.002522:0.008491:0.003607:0.012849:0.006464:0.009385:0.008124:0.007374:0.007933:0.004645:0.005411:0.009130:0.005299:0.005411:0.009034:0.008076:0.006049:0.009162:0.008731:0.003863:0.003863:0.008986:0.003863:0.008731:0.009162:0.003464:0.004373
He then had a cigarette outside the entrance and :@0.489919:0.380380:0.843967:0.380380:0.843967:0.369796:0.489919:0.369796:0.009992:0.007310:0.005714:0.005203:0.009034:0.008348:0.008826:0.006464:0.008571:0.007566:0.008826:0.006464:0.006895:0.006464:0.007374:0.003863:0.009178:0.007901:0.005554:0.008140:0.005411:0.005411:0.007996:0.006049:0.009162:0.008826:0.005203:0.006767:0.003655:0.009162:0.008060:0.005634:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005634:0.008348:0.009210:0.005411:0.005554:0.008124:0.009034:0.007374:0.008348:0.005969:0.007645:0.008491:0.008906:0.004373
returned to the emergency department, accompanied :@0.489499:0.394931:0.876937:0.394931:0.876937:0.384346:0.489499:0.384346:0.005379:0.008060:0.005411:0.008699:0.005554:0.008810:0.008156:0.009401:0.005890:0.005411:0.009130:0.005203:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005634:0.008348:0.013742:0.008348:0.005554:0.009401:0.008348:0.009034:0.007374:0.007725:0.005203:0.009401:0.008348:0.009561:0.008124:0.005554:0.005411:0.013918:0.008348:0.009210:0.005411:0.003464:0.006752:0.008124:0.007166:0.007374:0.009353:0.013423:0.009385:0.008124:0.008779:0.003863:0.008348:0.009210:0.004373
by the guards.  He asked for water.  One of the guards :@0.489499:0.409481:0.873921:0.409481:0.873921:0.398897:0.489499:0.398897:0.008651:0.007055:0.004868:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005634:0.009401:0.008667:0.008124:0.005315:0.009401:0.006560:0.003464:0.004373:0.003160:0.010247:0.007470:0.005634:0.007901:0.006560:0.007933:0.008028:0.009162:0.006049:0.004996:0.009545:0.005554:0.004373:0.011747:0.008124:0.005411:0.008555:0.005554:0.003464:0.004373:0.002490:0.011843:0.009034:0.008348:0.005475:0.009353:0.004756:0.005203:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005634:0.009162:0.008826:0.008124:0.005315:0.009162:0.006767:0.004373
went to the cooler and at that point the patient made :@0.488323:0.423972:0.878219:0.423972:0.878219:0.413388:0.488323:0.413388:0.012178:0.008906:0.009497:0.005714:0.005203:0.005123:0.008986:0.005299:0.005411:0.009034:0.008076:0.006049:0.007374:0.009178:0.009162:0.003863:0.008156:0.005554:0.005108:0.007805:0.008651:0.008986:0.006464:0.008124:0.005155:0.004868:0.005411:0.009369:0.008316:0.005411:0.005762:0.009162:0.009162:0.003863:0.008826:0.005411:0.005092:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006049:0.009385:0.008124:0.005411:0.003863:0.008076:0.009034:0.005411:0.005890:0.013280:0.007725:0.008986:0.007981:0.004373
his escape.  Unfortunately, the guards could  not catch :@0.489499:0.438522:0.872133:0.438522:0.872133:0.427938:0.489499:0.427938:0.008395:0.003527:0.006209:0.005634:0.008348:0.006767:0.007055:0.007901:0.009385:0.007996:0.003464:0.004373:0.002825:0.010965:0.008858:0.004996:0.009353:0.005554:0.005219:0.009034:0.009034:0.008124:0.005411:0.008348:0.003863:0.007725:0.003464:0.006065:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006049:0.009401:0.008571:0.008124:0.005235:0.009162:0.006767:0.005586:0.007135:0.008906:0.008731:0.003863:0.008826:0.004373:0.002522:0.008731:0.008986:0.005203:0.005299:0.007374:0.007661:0.005411:0.007023:0.008826:0.004373
him and  he ran  into the path of approaching vehicles.:@0.489499:0.453073:0.871957:0.453073:0.871957:0.442488:0.489499:0.442488:0.008491:0.003607:0.012944:0.006049:0.007805:0.008571:0.008986:0.004373:0.002522:0.008395:0.007725:0.006464:0.005123:0.007470:0.008316:0.004373:0.002522:0.003863:0.008571:0.005203:0.008986:0.005203:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006464:0.008986:0.007725:0.005203:0.008651:0.006049:0.009353:0.004756:0.005714:0.008124:0.009018:0.009385:0.005315:0.009353:0.007949:0.007374:0.008842:0.003863:0.009034:0.009194:0.005634:0.007470:0.008348:0.009034:0.003863:0.007151:0.003863:0.008348:0.006767:0.003464
It was claimed that the guards had failed to take :@0.489499:0.474160:0.838647:0.474160:0.838647:0.463575:0.489499:0.463575:0.003607:0.004453:0.004373:0.012434:0.008651:0.007230:0.005203:0.007374:0.003863:0.007741:0.003863:0.013439:0.008156:0.009401:0.005890:0.005411:0.009034:0.008316:0.005411:0.005251:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005634:0.009401:0.008747:0.008124:0.005554:0.009082:0.006767:0.006001:0.008571:0.007566:0.008826:0.005634:0.004996:0.007949:0.003863:0.003863:0.008060:0.009401:0.005890:0.005411:0.009034:0.005299:0.005411:0.007949:0.007933:0.008108:0.004373
appropriate care of the patient and  it was foreseeable :@0.489079:0.488710:0.876629:0.488710:0.876629:0.478126:0.489079:0.478126:0.008124:0.009178:0.009385:0.005554:0.009082:0.009385:0.005554:0.003623:0.008124:0.005235:0.008348:0.005938:0.007135:0.007725:0.005379:0.007981:0.005634:0.009353:0.005187:0.004868:0.005411:0.009034:0.008076:0.006049:0.009385:0.008124:0.005411:0.003863:0.008348:0.009034:0.005411:0.005283:0.007805:0.008651:0.008986:0.004373:0.002426:0.003368:0.004709:0.004868:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.005203:0.004996:0.009353:0.005554:0.008076:0.006767:0.008348:0.008156:0.008124:0.009178:0.003863:0.008348:0.004373
that if a door were left unattended even for a  brief time :@0.488743:0.503498:0.891903:0.503498:0.891903:0.492914:0.488743:0.492914:0.005411:0.009369:0.008316:0.005411:0.005762:0.003527:0.004533:0.005634:0.006799:0.006049:0.009401:0.009002:0.009353:0.005347:0.004373:0.011843:0.008651:0.005554:0.008731:0.006384:0.003863:0.008060:0.004996:0.005411:0.005554:0.009034:0.009034:0.008124:0.005219:0.005411:0.008348:0.008842:0.009401:0.008348:0.009210:0.006464:0.007901:0.007310:0.007981:0.008651:0.006049:0.004996:0.009545:0.005554:0.005363:0.006799:0.004373:0.002522:0.009162:0.005554:0.003687:0.008156:0.004996:0.004756:0.005411:0.003655:0.013439:0.008156:0.004373
Mr Walsh might escape. Judge Freedman  noted that the :@0.489919:0.518048:0.895042:0.518048:0.895042:0.507464:0.489919:0.507464:0.013695:0.005299:0.004373:0.014700:0.008124:0.003863:0.006767:0.009034:0.006736:0.013742:0.003639:0.009401:0.008667:0.005411:0.005507:0.008348:0.006767:0.007055:0.007901:0.009385:0.007996:0.003464:0.005938:0.005698:0.009034:0.009401:0.009401:0.008348:0.006081:0.007789:0.005315:0.008060:0.008156:0.009066:0.013439:0.007901:0.008826:0.004373:0.002522:0.008731:0.008986:0.005123:0.008060:0.008986:0.006049:0.005411:0.009034:0.008316:0.005411:0.005251:0.005411:0.008699:0.008060:0.004373
patient had  not been detained under the Mental  Health :@0.489499:0.532599:0.890680:0.532599:0.890680:0.522014:0.489499:0.522014:0.009385:0.007917:0.005411:0.003863:0.008348:0.009034:0.005411:0.005491:0.008491:0.007645:0.008906:0.004373:0.002426:0.008826:0.008986:0.005203:0.006049:0.008986:0.007901:0.007901:0.008651:0.006049:0.009401:0.008156:0.005411:0.007869:0.003863:0.008826:0.008156:0.009401:0.006736:0.009034:0.008779:0.009401:0.007981:0.005554:0.005203:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006384:0.013950:0.008156:0.008826:0.005411:0.007949:0.003863:0.004373:0.002761:0.010758:0.007805:0.007725:0.003607:0.005044:0.008571:0.004373
Act  1983 and therefore there was no statutory power :@0.488323:0.547149:0.876958:0.547149:0.876958:0.536565:0.488323:0.536565:0.010917:0.007645:0.005634:0.004373:0.002426:0.008603:0.008603:0.008603:0.008603:0.006337:0.007805:0.008651:0.008986:0.005634:0.005411:0.009034:0.008348:0.005554:0.008348:0.004996:0.009353:0.005554:0.008348:0.005618:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005554:0.008140:0.004788:0.012178:0.008571:0.007135:0.006049:0.008571:0.008731:0.005634:0.006767:0.005586:0.008124:0.005411:0.009034:0.005411:0.009353:0.005554:0.007725:0.005586:0.009385:0.009353:0.011540:0.008539:0.005554:0.004373
to confine him to hospital. While there was a  risk of :@0.488743:0.561700:0.863253:0.561700:0.863253:0.551115:0.488743:0.551115:0.005411:0.009034:0.005299:0.007374:0.009353:0.009034:0.004996:0.003863:0.009034:0.008348:0.006464:0.008491:0.003607:0.012849:0.006049:0.005123:0.008986:0.006049:0.009034:0.009034:0.006767:0.009114:0.003863:0.005411:0.007773:0.003863:0.003272:0.006049:0.014908:0.009369:0.003863:0.004038:0.008348:0.005842:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005554:0.008140:0.004788:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.005714:0.006799:0.004373:0.002522:0.005299:0.003863:0.006305:0.007470:0.005299:0.008906:0.004788:0.004373
the deceased absconding, the function of the security :@0.488743:0.576250:0.876979:0.576250:0.876979:0.565666:0.488743:0.565666:0.005411:0.009034:0.008076:0.005714:0.009066:0.008156:0.007374:0.007996:0.008124:0.006496:0.008156:0.009162:0.006384:0.008124:0.009385:0.006767:0.007374:0.009353:0.009034:0.009401:0.003863:0.009034:0.009401:0.003464:0.005953:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005203:0.004996:0.009034:0.009034:0.007374:0.005602:0.003863:0.009353:0.009210:0.006464:0.009353:0.004756:0.005299:0.005411:0.009034:0.008076:0.005714:0.006767:0.008348:0.007055:0.008826:0.005554:0.003687:0.005411:0.007534:0.004373
officers was not to detain him in the conventional sense :@0.489079:0.590740:0.891904:0.590740:0.891904:0.580156:0.489079:0.580156:0.009353:0.004996:0.004996:0.003863:0.007198:0.008348:0.005347:0.006767:0.004820:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.006049:0.008826:0.008986:0.005203:0.005203:0.005411:0.009130:0.005634:0.009066:0.008156:0.005411:0.007869:0.003863:0.008826:0.006384:0.008651:0.003863:0.012944:0.006464:0.003272:0.007566:0.006049:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005634:0.007374:0.009353:0.009034:0.007645:0.008172:0.009034:0.005411:0.003863:0.009162:0.009034:0.008124:0.003863:0.006289:0.006464:0.007981:0.008651:0.006464:0.007981:0.004373
but rather to take reasonable steps to prevent him :@0.489499:0.605290:0.851176:0.605290:0.851176:0.594706:0.489499:0.594706:0.009066:0.008731:0.005203:0.005634:0.005554:0.008124:0.005411:0.009034:0.008348:0.005554:0.004772:0.005411:0.009130:0.005203:0.005411:0.008124:0.008220:0.008348:0.006193:0.005554:0.008140:0.008124:0.006767:0.009050:0.009034:0.007853:0.009385:0.003639:0.008348:0.005602:0.006560:0.005203:0.008060:0.009066:0.006560:0.005203:0.005411:0.009130:0.006049:0.009385:0.005235:0.008156:0.007470:0.008156:0.008826:0.005203:0.006049:0.008395:0.003527:0.012689:0.004373
from leaving.  In the short period  prior to him running :@0.488743:0.619841:0.872877:0.619841:0.872877:0.609256:0.488743:0.609256:0.004788:0.005554:0.009146:0.013519:0.006464:0.003863:0.008060:0.008124:0.007326:0.003863:0.008731:0.009066:0.003464:0.004373:0.002745:0.003607:0.007725:0.005634:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006049:0.006767:0.008683:0.009162:0.005554:0.005411:0.005922:0.008906:0.007901:0.005299:0.003863:0.008731:0.008906:0.004373:0.002426:0.009066:0.005299:0.003863:0.008731:0.005299:0.005299:0.005123:0.008986:0.006049:0.008571:0.003863:0.012944:0.006464:0.005554:0.008810:0.008731:0.008826:0.003863:0.008651:0.009162:0.004373
away, there was nothing in  his demeanour to suggest :@0.489079:0.634391:0.875783:0.634391:0.875783:0.623807:0.489079:0.623807:0.008124:0.011284:0.008124:0.007422:0.003464:0.006368:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005554:0.008140:0.004868:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.006049:0.008826:0.009162:0.005411:0.008779:0.003863:0.008731:0.009401:0.006736:0.003272:0.007566:0.004373:0.002522:0.008395:0.003527:0.006209:0.005634:0.009401:0.008348:0.013918:0.008348:0.008124:0.009241:0.009353:0.009210:0.005554:0.004772:0.005411:0.009130:0.005634:0.006767:0.008683:0.009162:0.009162:0.008060:0.006767:0.005076:0.004373
he was contemplating an escape. On the contrary, the :@0.489499:0.648882:0.879379:0.648882:0.879379:0.638298:0.489499:0.638298:0.008395:0.007725:0.004868:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.005634:0.007374:0.009178:0.009034:0.005411:0.008348:0.013742:0.009385:0.003863:0.008124:0.005411:0.003863:0.009034:0.009401:0.006289:0.007645:0.008491:0.006049:0.008348:0.006767:0.007151:0.008124:0.009178:0.008348:0.003464:0.006752:0.011253:0.008491:0.006049:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005634:0.007374:0.009002:0.008826:0.005203:0.005379:0.008124:0.005235:0.007725:0.003192:0.006049:0.005411:0.008699:0.008060:0.004373
evidence suggested  he was calm and co-operative.  It :@0.489079:0.663433:0.869255:0.663433:0.869255:0.652848:0.489079:0.652848:0.008348:0.007438:0.003863:0.009162:0.008348:0.008699:0.007374:0.008076:0.005634:0.006560:0.008826:0.009401:0.009082:0.008156:0.006767:0.005155:0.008348:0.009130:0.004373:0.002426:0.008395:0.007725:0.004868:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.005634:0.007135:0.007901:0.003863:0.013359:0.006049:0.007805:0.008651:0.008986:0.006464:0.007374:0.009178:0.006384:0.009066:0.009385:0.007996:0.005554:0.007885:0.005411:0.003863:0.007438:0.008156:0.003464:0.004373:0.002825:0.003368:0.004278:0.004373
was reasonable for one of the guards to respond to :@0.488323:0.677983:0.860853:0.677983:0.860853:0.667399:0.488323:0.667399:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.006049:0.005554:0.008140:0.008124:0.006496:0.009162:0.009034:0.007773:0.009385:0.003639:0.008156:0.005634:0.004996:0.009545:0.005554:0.005283:0.009162:0.009034:0.008012:0.005634:0.009353:0.004756:0.005299:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005634:0.009401:0.008571:0.008124:0.005235:0.009162:0.006767:0.005155:0.005411:0.009130:0.006049:0.005203:0.007981:0.006560:0.009066:0.008986:0.008731:0.009066:0.005634:0.005123:0.008986:0.004373
the request for water.  To hold guards negligent in such :@0.488743:0.692534:0.882996:0.692534:0.882996:0.681949:0.488743:0.681949:0.005411:0.009034:0.008076:0.006049:0.005379:0.008060:0.009401:0.008747:0.008156:0.006767:0.005155:0.005203:0.004996:0.009545:0.005554:0.004373:0.011540:0.008348:0.005411:0.008539:0.005554:0.003464:0.004373:0.002490:0.007310:0.008060:0.006049:0.008395:0.008651:0.003607:0.008731:0.006464:0.009162:0.008826:0.008124:0.005315:0.009162:0.006767:0.005922:0.009034:0.008348:0.009162:0.003863:0.003863:0.009401:0.008156:0.009034:0.005411:0.005459:0.003368:0.007901:0.006049:0.006384:0.008571:0.007055:0.008651:0.004373
circumstances would  be to impose an  intolerably high :@0.489079:0.707084:0.876565:0.707084:0.876565:0.696500:0.489079:0.696500:0.007374:0.003863:0.005315:0.007374:0.009034:0.013742:0.006767:0.005411:0.008124:0.009034:0.007374:0.008348:0.006767:0.004724:0.011540:0.009720:0.009034:0.004070:0.009577:0.004373:0.002522:0.008571:0.007566:0.005203:0.005411:0.009130:0.006049:0.003863:0.013280:0.009066:0.009162:0.006560:0.008060:0.005714:0.007645:0.008491:0.004373:0.002426:0.003863:0.009034:0.005171:0.009162:0.003863:0.008348:0.005347:0.008124:0.009098:0.003863:0.007725:0.005459:0.008571:0.003607:0.008731:0.008491:0.004373
burden  upon them. The guards had not been  negligent :@0.489499:0.721574:0.888333:0.721574:0.888333:0.710989:0.489499:0.710989:0.008986:0.008651:0.005299:0.009066:0.008060:0.008731:0.004373:0.002522:0.008651:0.008826:0.008906:0.008651:0.006049:0.005411:0.009210:0.008348:0.013918:0.003464:0.006448:0.008364:0.008779:0.008348:0.005602:0.009401:0.008747:0.008124:0.005315:0.009401:0.006560:0.006049:0.008491:0.007645:0.008906:0.006384:0.009034:0.009114:0.005411:0.005507:0.008986:0.007901:0.007901:0.008651:0.004373:0.002522:0.008826:0.008156:0.009401:0.003623:0.003863:0.009162:0.008156:0.009034:0.005155:0.004373
and, in any event, causation  had  not been demonstrated :@0.489079:0.736124:0.897506:0.736124:0.897506:0.725540:0.489079:0.725540:0.008124:0.009034:0.009401:0.003464:0.006688:0.003272:0.007645:0.006464:0.008124:0.008763:0.007725:0.005219:0.008348:0.007645:0.008348:0.008763:0.005411:0.003464:0.006416:0.007374:0.008124:0.008858:0.006767:0.007933:0.005411:0.003863:0.009353:0.008842:0.004373:0.002426:0.008491:0.007645:0.008906:0.004373:0.002522:0.008731:0.008986:0.005203:0.006049:0.008906:0.007805:0.007805:0.008571:0.006464:0.009401:0.008348:0.013742:0.009082:0.009034:0.006592:0.005411:0.005554:0.007853:0.005411:0.008348:0.009178:0.004373
because it was probable that Mr Walsh would  have :@0.489499:0.750675:0.858805:0.750675:0.858805:0.740090:0.489499:0.740090:0.009162:0.008156:0.007374:0.007741:0.008826:0.006767:0.008012:0.006464:0.003368:0.004709:0.004373:0.012434:0.008651:0.007230:0.006049:0.009162:0.005379:0.008986:0.009066:0.007805:0.009066:0.003863:0.007981:0.005634:0.005411:0.009369:0.008316:0.005411:0.006177:0.013615:0.005299:0.004868:0.014700:0.008124:0.003863:0.006767:0.009034:0.005060:0.011540:0.009720:0.009034:0.004070:0.009577:0.004373:0.002522:0.008731:0.007725:0.007390:0.007981:0.004373
found another opportunity to end  his life within a short :@0.488743:0.765225:0.889892:0.765225:0.889892:0.754641:0.488743:0.754641:0.004996:0.009353:0.008842:0.009034:0.009401:0.006352:0.008124:0.009034:0.009561:0.005411:0.009034:0.008348:0.005554:0.005427:0.009353:0.009385:0.009385:0.009353:0.005554:0.005411:0.009034:0.009034:0.003863:0.005411:0.007725:0.004788:0.005411:0.009130:0.005634:0.007901:0.008571:0.008906:0.004373:0.002522:0.008395:0.003527:0.006209:0.006049:0.003863:0.003448:0.004613:0.007805:0.005299:0.011843:0.003863:0.005714:0.009241:0.003863:0.009417:0.006049:0.006799:0.006464:0.006767:0.008603:0.009066:0.005554:0.005108:0.004373
time, even if he had been  restrained on this occasion.:@0.488743:0.779776:0.869190:0.779776:0.869190:0.769191:0.488743:0.769191:0.005411:0.003863:0.013742:0.008156:0.003464:0.006448:0.008060:0.007390:0.008060:0.008731:0.006464:0.003863:0.004629:0.005634:0.008395:0.007725:0.006464:0.008571:0.007566:0.008826:0.006464:0.008906:0.007981:0.007981:0.008651:0.004373:0.002426:0.005554:0.008060:0.006767:0.005076:0.005379:0.007901:0.003863:0.008731:0.008060:0.009162:0.006464:0.008571:0.008395:0.006049:0.005411:0.008699:0.003863:0.006560:0.005714:0.009353:0.007198:0.007374:0.007917:0.006767:0.003655:0.009162:0.009034:0.003464
Comment:@0.489079:0.802411:0.564667:0.802411:0.564667:0.791270:0.489079:0.791270:0.010484:0.009845:0.014953:0.014953:0.008905:0.009913:0.006536
This was a very sad case,  but it is important to bear :@0.488726:0.823370:0.858001:0.823370:0.858001:0.812785:0.488726:0.812785:0.008364:0.008603:0.003863:0.006560:0.004868:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.005634:0.006895:0.005203:0.007645:0.008348:0.005554:0.007518:0.005203:0.006384:0.007470:0.008731:0.006464:0.007374:0.007917:0.006767:0.008348:0.003464:0.004373:0.002410:0.009066:0.008731:0.005203:0.006049:0.003368:0.004709:0.005634:0.003368:0.005969:0.005634:0.003863:0.013742:0.009385:0.009353:0.005554:0.005411:0.008124:0.009034:0.005411:0.005139:0.005411:0.009034:0.005714:0.009066:0.007981:0.007805:0.005379:0.004373
in  mind that the patient was not detained under :@0.489483:0.837920:0.838726:0.837920:0.838726:0.827336:0.489483:0.827336:0.003272:0.007645:0.004373:0.002426:0.013024:0.003863:0.008395:0.008986:0.006049:0.005411:0.009034:0.008316:0.005411:0.005347:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006049:0.009385:0.008124:0.005411:0.003863:0.008076:0.009034:0.005411:0.004709:0.012098:0.008571:0.007135:0.006049:0.008826:0.008986:0.005203:0.005634:0.009401:0.008156:0.005411:0.007869:0.003863:0.008826:0.008156:0.009401:0.006225:0.009034:0.008779:0.009401:0.008076:0.005554:0.004373
the Mental  Health Act. The claim sought to place an :@0.488726:0.852471:0.865694:0.852471:0.865694:0.841886:0.488726:0.841886:0.005411:0.009034:0.008076:0.006464:0.014030:0.008156:0.008731:0.005411:0.007869:0.003863:0.004373:0.002857:0.010838:0.007901:0.007725:0.003863:0.004964:0.008651:0.005634:0.010758:0.007566:0.005634:0.003464:0.006448:0.008364:0.008858:0.008348:0.005938:0.007135:0.003863:0.007725:0.003863:0.013280:0.006049:0.006767:0.009353:0.008826:0.009401:0.009034:0.005411:0.004804:0.005411:0.009130:0.006049:0.009066:0.003863:0.007725:0.007135:0.008060:0.005714:0.007390:0.008316:0.004373
unreasonably high  burden  upon the guards who had :@0.489483:0.866962:0.869227:0.866962:0.869227:0.856377:0.489483:0.856377:0.009034:0.008858:0.005554:0.008140:0.008124:0.006767:0.009353:0.009034:0.008124:0.009385:0.003863:0.007725:0.005666:0.008571:0.003607:0.008731:0.008491:0.004373:0.002522:0.008986:0.008651:0.005299:0.009066:0.008060:0.008731:0.004373:0.002426:0.008731:0.008986:0.009066:0.008731:0.005634:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006049:0.009401:0.008571:0.008124:0.005235:0.009162:0.006767:0.004740:0.012258:0.009656:0.009912:0.005634:0.008395:0.007470:0.008731:0.004373
no immediate reason to think the patient was going to :@0.489483:0.881453:0.884566:0.881453:0.884566:0.870868:0.489483:0.870868:0.008571:0.008826:0.006049:0.003863:0.013439:0.013519:0.008348:0.009210:0.003863:0.007901:0.005411:0.008348:0.006321:0.005299:0.007981:0.007805:0.006464:0.008906:0.008651:0.006049:0.005123:0.008986:0.005299:0.005634:0.009321:0.003863:0.009321:0.008156:0.004788:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006049:0.009385:0.008124:0.005411:0.003863:0.008348:0.009034:0.005411:0.004373:0.012242:0.008571:0.007135:0.005634:0.008986:0.008986:0.003863:0.008571:0.009066:0.006049:0.005044:0.008651:0.004373
escape and were performing an act of kindness for him. :@0.489062:0.896061:0.891903:0.896061:0.891903:0.885477:0.489062:0.885477:0.008156:0.006767:0.007087:0.007901:0.009162:0.008156:0.006049:0.007805:0.008571:0.008986:0.005299:0.011923:0.008731:0.005554:0.008810:0.006049:0.009385:0.008172:0.005554:0.004996:0.009114:0.005554:0.013519:0.003863:0.008826:0.009401:0.006305:0.007645:0.008491:0.006049:0.008124:0.007374:0.005411:0.005299:0.009353:0.004756:0.006049:0.007933:0.003655:0.009034:0.009114:0.008826:0.008348:0.006528:0.006767:0.005155:0.004996:0.009545:0.005554:0.006129:0.008651:0.003863:0.012849:0.003272:0.004373
This is a notable ruling, although as it is a County Court :@0.488726:0.910612:0.890625:0.910612:0.890625:0.900027:0.488726:0.900027:0.008364:0.008603:0.003863:0.006560:0.006049:0.003192:0.005714:0.005634:0.006799:0.006464:0.009034:0.009114:0.005411:0.007949:0.009385:0.003863:0.008092:0.006049:0.005554:0.009034:0.003863:0.003639:0.008826:0.009401:0.003192:0.006464:0.008124:0.003863:0.005411:0.009034:0.009353:0.008826:0.009401:0.009034:0.005922:0.007725:0.006384:0.006049:0.003368:0.004709:0.006049:0.003192:0.005714:0.005634:0.006799:0.006049:0.010087:0.009577:0.009241:0.009321:0.005411:0.008028:0.005203:0.010087:0.009353:0.009289:0.005554:0.005618:0.004373
judgment it is not binding on other judges.  It is clear :@0.487886:0.925162:0.867695:0.925162:0.867695:0.914578:0.487886:0.914578:0.003863:0.009241:0.009401:0.009672:0.014030:0.008348:0.009385:0.005411:0.006097:0.003368:0.004709:0.005634:0.003368:0.005874:0.005634:0.009034:0.009114:0.005411:0.005507:0.009066:0.003863:0.008491:0.009066:0.003863:0.008571:0.009066:0.006464:0.008571:0.008395:0.006384:0.009353:0.005411:0.008842:0.008348:0.005554:0.004070:0.003863:0.009241:0.009401:0.009401:0.008348:0.006767:0.003464:0.004373:0.002761:0.003783:0.004709:0.005634:0.003192:0.005714:0.005634:0.007374:0.003863:0.007996:0.008124:0.005315:0.004373
from the decision that the duty of security guards in such :@0.488726:0.939653:0.900377:0.939653:0.900377:0.929069:0.488726:0.929069:0.004788:0.005554:0.009146:0.013519:0.005634:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.006049:0.009162:0.008060:0.007135:0.003863:0.006384:0.003863:0.008826:0.008731:0.006049:0.005411:0.009369:0.008316:0.005411:0.005012:0.005411:0.009034:0.008156:0.005634:0.009401:0.008826:0.005411:0.007725:0.005347:0.009353:0.004756:0.005203:0.006767:0.008348:0.007374:0.008763:0.005554:0.003863:0.005411:0.007518:0.005299:0.009401:0.008747:0.008124:0.005315:0.009401:0.006560:0.005634:0.003368:0.007981:0.006049:0.006384:0.008571:0.007055:0.008651:0.004373
circumstances is one of reasonable care and  no higher.:@0.489062:0.955094:0.877235:0.955094:0.877235:0.944510:0.489062:0.944510:0.007374:0.003863:0.005315:0.007374:0.009034:0.013742:0.006767:0.005411:0.008124:0.009034:0.007374:0.008348:0.006767:0.005985:0.003192:0.005634:0.005634:0.008986:0.008826:0.008060:0.006049:0.009353:0.004756:0.006049:0.005554:0.008060:0.008124:0.006496:0.009162:0.009034:0.007773:0.009385:0.003639:0.008156:0.006049:0.007135:0.007725:0.005379:0.007981:0.005634:0.007805:0.008651:0.008986:0.004373:0.002426:0.008571:0.008826:0.006049:0.008571:0.003607:0.008826:0.008571:0.007901:0.005203:0.003464