NHS Resolution:@0.116465:0.056159:0.212674:0.056159:0.212674:0.047246:0.116465:0.047246:0.009566:0.009324:0.006892:0.004864:0.008397:0.006973:0.005710:0.007981:0.003816:0.007766:0.005226:0.003587:0.007981:0.008128 Annual report and accounts 2021/22:@0.288185:0.056159:0.513709:0.056159:0.513709:0.047246:0.288185:0.047246:0.009230:0.008142:0.008061:0.008142:0.007215:0.003520:0.005629:0.004958:0.007309:0.008222:0.008236:0.004864:0.004555:0.005011:0.006839:0.007604:0.007725:0.005213:0.006839:0.006422:0.006382:0.008061:0.007806:0.007604:0.004743:0.005697:0.004460:0.006879:0.006973:0.006879:0.006973:0.005038:0.007053:0.007242 41:@0.937106:0.056159:0.951469:0.056159:0.951469:0.047246:0.937106:0.047246:0.006637:0.007725 Paul v. Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust;:@0.096734:0.103397:0.444890:0.103397:0.444890:0.092256:0.096734:0.092256:0.010496:0.009035:0.010160:0.004988:0.006466:0.008313:0.004115:0.004635:0.003090:0.011504:0.010664:0.009321:0.009489:0.004954:0.006046:0.018557:0.011252:0.005206:0.009908:0.009992:0.007221:0.011084:0.009825:0.016878:0.011336:0.007053:0.011252:0.011084:0.006886:0.013267:0.012864:0.009421:0.005928:0.010076:0.006684:0.010446:0.007389:0.006718:0.004551 :@0.444958:0.103397:0.449559:0.103397:0.449559:0.092256:0.444958:0.092256:0.004602 Polmear v. Royal Cornwall NHS Trust; Purchase:@0.096734:0.118779:0.497708:0.118779:0.497708:0.107637:0.096734:0.107637:0.010916:0.010832:0.005038:0.016290:0.009573:0.009573:0.007137:0.005626:0.008313:0.004199:0.004635:0.003006:0.011504:0.010664:0.009321:0.009489:0.004954:0.004635:0.002586:0.011504:0.011252:0.007389:0.011168:0.014611:0.009908:0.005206:0.005206:0.004635:0.002586:0.013267:0.012512:0.009421:0.006281:0.010160:0.006886:0.010412:0.007557:0.006718:0.004551:0.006953:0.011000:0.010748:0.007053:0.008565:0.010748:0.009489:0.007809:0.009086 :@0.498178:0.118779:0.502779:0.118779:0.502779:0.107637:0.498178:0.107637:0.004602 v. Ahmed (Court of Appeal, 13 January 2022):@0.095894:0.134457:0.481972:0.134457:0.481972:0.123315:0.095894:0.123315:0.008313:0.004199:0.006466:0.012679:0.010916:0.016626:0.009825:0.011252:0.006802:0.006718:0.011168:0.010916:0.010832:0.007053:0.006970:0.006046:0.010832:0.006886:0.005206:0.013099:0.011420:0.011420:0.009992:0.009908:0.005290:0.004954:0.006886:0.009069:0.009069:0.006466:0.008145:0.009992:0.011168:0.011168:0.009825:0.007389:0.009992:0.005626:0.009825:0.009825:0.009657:0.009992:0.006197 Introduction:@0.096734:0.156135:0.192292:0.156135:0.192292:0.144993:0.096734:0.144993:0.004954:0.009657:0.006298:0.006466:0.009825:0.009992:0.009741:0.007725:0.006298:0.004770:0.009673:0.010160 These three cases all involved similar issues concerning :@0.095894:0.178281:0.487780:0.178281:0.487780:0.167697:0.095894:0.167697:0.008360:0.008775:0.008344:0.006765:0.008073:0.005297:0.005409:0.009030:0.005377:0.008344:0.008121:0.005632:0.007371:0.007738:0.006765:0.008105:0.006765:0.005584:0.007227:0.003446:0.003446:0.006461:0.003606:0.008727:0.007387:0.008982:0.003861:0.007227:0.007977:0.009062:0.006382:0.006765:0.003654:0.013354:0.003861:0.003861:0.007818:0.005552:0.005951:0.003606:0.006557:0.006461:0.008727:0.007977:0.006557:0.005297:0.007371:0.009349:0.009030:0.007084:0.008344:0.005552:0.008855:0.003861:0.009030:0.009397:0.004371 secondary victims of alleged clinical negligence.:@0.096314:0.193662:0.433413:0.193662:0.433413:0.183078:0.096314:0.183078:0.006765:0.008344:0.007371:0.009094:0.009030:0.009190:0.008121:0.005552:0.007483:0.004371:0.007642:0.003861:0.007371:0.005409:0.003861:0.013737:0.006573:0.005632:0.009349:0.004754:0.005632:0.008121:0.003558:0.003861:0.007897:0.009062:0.008057:0.009062:0.006382:0.007132:0.003861:0.003606:0.008727:0.003861:0.007132:0.007897:0.003861:0.006302:0.009030:0.008105:0.009397:0.003861:0.003622:0.009397:0.008153:0.009030:0.007179:0.008344:0.003462 A secondary victim is not someone to whom :@0.095558:0.209342:0.416671:0.209342:0.416671:0.198758:0.095558:0.198758:0.011248:0.005201:0.006765:0.008344:0.007148:0.009349:0.009030:0.009397:0.008121:0.005552:0.007722:0.004371:0.007642:0.003638:0.007371:0.005137:0.003861:0.013434:0.006461:0.003366:0.005967:0.005632:0.009030:0.009030:0.005409:0.005169:0.006765:0.009014:0.013737:0.008089:0.009349:0.009030:0.008073:0.005632:0.005409:0.009126:0.004786:0.011535:0.009285:0.009349:0.014167:0.004371 the defendant owed a direct duty of care in the :@0.095894:0.224724:0.438864:0.224724:0.438864:0.214139:0.095894:0.214139:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.005632:0.009573:0.008344:0.005265:0.008344:0.009206:0.009397:0.008121:0.009269:0.005409:0.005345:0.009349:0.011535:0.008344:0.009397:0.006461:0.006892:0.006047:0.009158:0.003861:0.005377:0.008153:0.007371:0.005137:0.005297:0.009397:0.008823:0.005409:0.007722:0.005345:0.009349:0.004754:0.005201:0.007371:0.007738:0.005377:0.008153:0.006047:0.003271:0.007562:0.006047:0.005409:0.008695:0.008057:0.004371 circumstances (the primary victim), but rather a person :@0.096314:0.240106:0.488024:0.240106:0.488024:0.229521:0.096314:0.229521:0.007371:0.003861:0.005313:0.007371:0.009030:0.013737:0.006557:0.005409:0.008121:0.009030:0.007371:0.008344:0.006765:0.005760:0.004611:0.005409:0.008775:0.008153:0.006047:0.009381:0.005552:0.003622:0.013513:0.008121:0.005552:0.007483:0.004371:0.007642:0.003861:0.007371:0.005409:0.003861:0.013737:0.004818:0.003462:0.004371:0.002728:0.009062:0.008727:0.005201:0.005632:0.005552:0.008121:0.005409:0.009030:0.008344:0.005552:0.005185:0.006797:0.004371:0.002521:0.008903:0.007897:0.005297:0.006461:0.008823:0.008567:0.004371 who witnessed the accident or event involving the :@0.095558:0.255488:0.458232:0.255488:0.458232:0.244903:0.095558:0.244903:0.012093:0.009493:0.009828:0.004866:0.011535:0.003861:0.005600:0.009030:0.008520:0.006765:0.006765:0.008552:0.009397:0.005712:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006047:0.008121:0.007371:0.007371:0.003861:0.009397:0.008344:0.009030:0.005409:0.005584:0.008823:0.005297:0.005201:0.008344:0.007642:0.008344:0.009030:0.005409:0.005568:0.003861:0.008567:0.007387:0.008982:0.003861:0.007227:0.003861:0.008488:0.009062:0.006047:0.005409:0.008695:0.008057:0.004371 primary victim or who came upon its consequences :@0.096734:0.270929:0.465932:0.270929:0.465932:0.260344:0.096734:0.260344:0.009158:0.005552:0.003685:0.013434:0.008121:0.005313:0.007722:0.004371:0.007467:0.003861:0.007371:0.005233:0.003861:0.013737:0.005919:0.008823:0.005297:0.004866:0.012093:0.009493:0.009828:0.005632:0.007371:0.007913:0.013737:0.008089:0.006047:0.008647:0.008982:0.009062:0.008727:0.004371:0.002521:0.003526:0.004866:0.006126:0.005632:0.007371:0.009349:0.009030:0.006573:0.008344:0.009206:0.009030:0.008344:0.008823:0.007371:0.008169:0.006765:0.004371 shortly afterwards. The Court had to decide whether, :@0.096314:0.286310:0.478053:0.286310:0.478053:0.275725:0.096314:0.275725:0.006765:0.008679:0.009158:0.005552:0.005409:0.003654:0.007722:0.005042:0.008312:0.004994:0.005584:0.008344:0.005760:0.011758:0.008312:0.005552:0.009652:0.006765:0.003462:0.006573:0.008360:0.008855:0.008344:0.005935:0.010163:0.009573:0.009238:0.005791:0.005409:0.005760:0.008567:0.007562:0.008823:0.006047:0.005409:0.009126:0.005632:0.009158:0.008153:0.007371:0.003622:0.009158:0.008153:0.004786:0.011535:0.009206:0.008344:0.005600:0.009030:0.008344:0.005807:0.003462:0.004371 on the facts of each case, secondary victims might be :@0.096314:0.301988:0.480414:0.301988:0.480414:0.291404:0.096314:0.291404:0.008567:0.008392:0.005632:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.005632:0.004994:0.008121:0.007626:0.005409:0.006940:0.005632:0.009349:0.004754:0.005201:0.008153:0.008121:0.007084:0.009030:0.005919:0.007371:0.007913:0.006765:0.008344:0.003462:0.006446:0.006765:0.008344:0.007148:0.009349:0.009030:0.009397:0.008121:0.005552:0.007722:0.004371:0.007642:0.003861:0.007371:0.005409:0.003861:0.013529:0.006765:0.005999:0.013513:0.003861:0.009158:0.008823:0.005409:0.005584:0.008312:0.007387:0.004371 able to recover damages. This ruling was not about :@0.096314:0.317370:0.465991:0.317370:0.465991:0.306786:0.096314:0.306786:0.007897:0.008982:0.003861:0.007897:0.005201:0.005409:0.009126:0.006047:0.005552:0.007961:0.007371:0.008998:0.007467:0.008057:0.005377:0.005201:0.009397:0.008121:0.013737:0.008121:0.009158:0.008344:0.006765:0.003287:0.006461:0.008360:0.008599:0.003861:0.006557:0.006047:0.005297:0.008727:0.003861:0.003526:0.008647:0.009062:0.005632:0.012093:0.008567:0.007132:0.006047:0.008823:0.008982:0.005201:0.005201:0.008121:0.009381:0.009349:0.009030:0.005409:0.004371 whether the clinicians involved had been negligent.:@0.095558:0.332752:0.461167:0.332752:0.461167:0.322168:0.095558:0.322168:0.011918:0.009493:0.008647:0.005712:0.009397:0.008647:0.005791:0.004866:0.005409:0.009030:0.008073:0.006047:0.007371:0.003622:0.003861:0.009030:0.003861:0.007179:0.003861:0.008121:0.008839:0.006765:0.005999:0.003606:0.008647:0.007307:0.008903:0.003861:0.007132:0.007977:0.008982:0.004371:0.002521:0.008488:0.007642:0.008903:0.004371:0.002425:0.008903:0.007977:0.007977:0.008647:0.006382:0.009030:0.008344:0.009078:0.003861:0.003861:0.009078:0.008153:0.009030:0.005153:0.003462 Detail:@0.096734:0.355387:0.141305:0.355387:0.141305:0.344245:0.096734:0.344245:0.011756:0.008733:0.006130:0.008649:0.004534:0.004770 Mr Paul, who suffered from type 2 diabetes, was :@0.097153:0.376939:0.448148:0.376939:0.448148:0.366355:0.097153:0.366355:0.013609:0.005297:0.006047:0.008488:0.007802:0.008647:0.003861:0.003111:0.005632:0.012253:0.009652:0.009908:0.005632:0.006765:0.008775:0.004994:0.004994:0.007977:0.005552:0.008137:0.009397:0.005887:0.004994:0.005552:0.009014:0.013513:0.005632:0.005409:0.007435:0.009381:0.007993:0.005632:0.007642:0.006461:0.009397:0.003861:0.008121:0.009110:0.008344:0.005409:0.008073:0.006765:0.003462:0.005552:0.011918:0.008488:0.007052:0.004371 admitted to hospital on 9 November 2012 complaining :@0.096314:0.392617:0.493417:0.392617:0.493417:0.382032:0.096314:0.382032:0.008121:0.009094:0.013434:0.003861:0.005409:0.005169:0.008153:0.009397:0.005887:0.005409:0.009126:0.005632:0.008823:0.008982:0.006461:0.009062:0.003861:0.005201:0.007802:0.003861:0.006382:0.008567:0.008392:0.006461:0.008057:0.006382:0.011679:0.009062:0.007467:0.008344:0.013242:0.009158:0.008344:0.005265:0.005297:0.008982:0.009062:0.008903:0.008903:0.006047:0.007371:0.009094:0.013737:0.009110:0.003861:0.008121:0.003638:0.009030:0.003861:0.008775:0.009397:0.004371 of chest and jaw pain. He was treated for acute :@0.096314:0.407999:0.439236:0.407999:0.439236:0.397414:0.096314:0.397414:0.009349:0.004754:0.005297:0.007371:0.009030:0.008344:0.006493:0.005409:0.005249:0.007802:0.008567:0.008982:0.005297:0.004276:0.008903:0.012588:0.005632:0.009158:0.007897:0.003861:0.008823:0.003462:0.004371:0.003159:0.010243:0.007467:0.004866:0.012093:0.008567:0.007132:0.005201:0.005409:0.005345:0.008344:0.007786:0.005409:0.008105:0.009397:0.005887:0.004994:0.009541:0.005552:0.005696:0.008121:0.006988:0.009030:0.005153:0.008153:0.004371 coronary symptoms and discharged on 12 November.:@0.096314:0.423380:0.475420:0.423380:0.475420:0.412796:0.096314:0.412796:0.007371:0.009094:0.005552:0.009142:0.009030:0.008121:0.005361:0.007722:0.005121:0.006765:0.007722:0.013481:0.009381:0.005233:0.009349:0.013497:0.006765:0.005664:0.007802:0.008567:0.008982:0.006047:0.009397:0.003622:0.006765:0.007004:0.009030:0.007770:0.005552:0.009142:0.008344:0.009126:0.006461:0.008567:0.008392:0.004371:0.003685:0.007642:0.007642:0.004371:0.002521:0.011248:0.008823:0.007227:0.007977:0.013019:0.008903:0.007977:0.005297:0.003462 On 26 January 2014, some 14 months later, he had a :@0.096314:0.438823:0.480845:0.438823:0.480845:0.428239:0.096314:0.428239:0.011248:0.008488:0.006047:0.008903:0.008903:0.004786:0.005967:0.008121:0.009349:0.009238:0.008121:0.005728:0.007897:0.005297:0.009062:0.009158:0.009158:0.009238:0.003701:0.006382:0.006765:0.008934:0.013354:0.008057:0.004371:0.002856:0.008232:0.008312:0.005632:0.013737:0.009349:0.008823:0.005409:0.008775:0.006765:0.005999:0.003861:0.007483:0.005042:0.007802:0.005201:0.003271:0.004371:0.002521:0.008392:0.007722:0.006382:0.008488:0.007642:0.008903:0.006461:0.006461:0.004371 heart attack while shopping with his family and died :@0.096734:0.454205:0.473479:0.454205:0.473479:0.443620:0.096734:0.443620:0.009030:0.008105:0.008121:0.005313:0.005409:0.005504:0.008312:0.005409:0.005409:0.008408:0.007562:0.007929:0.004579:0.011838:0.009397:0.004036:0.004036:0.008567:0.006047:0.006765:0.008679:0.009062:0.009158:0.009158:0.003861:0.008647:0.009158:0.005632:0.011758:0.003861:0.005712:0.009317:0.004371:0.002521:0.008392:0.003526:0.006206:0.005201:0.004994:0.008121:0.014088:0.003861:0.003861:0.007722:0.005297:0.007802:0.008647:0.008982:0.006382:0.008647:0.003606:0.007642:0.008727:0.004371 shortly afterwards. His young daughters witnessed :@0.096314:0.469585:0.459450:0.469585:0.459450:0.459001:0.096314:0.459001:0.006765:0.008679:0.009158:0.005552:0.005409:0.003654:0.007722:0.005042:0.008312:0.004994:0.005584:0.008344:0.005760:0.011758:0.008312:0.005552:0.009652:0.006765:0.003462:0.004371:0.003462:0.010163:0.003446:0.006126:0.004786:0.007722:0.009078:0.009030:0.008855:0.009397:0.006302:0.009397:0.008121:0.009030:0.009397:0.009030:0.005409:0.008344:0.005552:0.006765:0.004786:0.011535:0.003861:0.005680:0.009030:0.008344:0.006765:0.006765:0.008344:0.009397:0.004371 his collapse and suffered psychiatric trauma. It was :@0.096734:0.485264:0.461401:0.485264:0.461401:0.474680:0.096734:0.474680:0.008392:0.003526:0.006206:0.005632:0.007371:0.008918:0.003861:0.003861:0.007818:0.009062:0.006765:0.008009:0.006047:0.007802:0.008567:0.008982:0.006047:0.006765:0.008775:0.004994:0.004994:0.007977:0.005552:0.008137:0.009397:0.006733:0.009381:0.006573:0.007722:0.007371:0.008839:0.003861:0.008121:0.005233:0.005552:0.003861:0.007371:0.004707:0.005409:0.005552:0.008360:0.009030:0.013976:0.008121:0.003462:0.004371:0.002936:0.003781:0.004707:0.004371:0.011998:0.008392:0.007052:0.004371 alleged that Mr Paul should have been given a coronary :@0.096314:0.500645:0.497740:0.500645:0.497740:0.490061:0.096314:0.490061:0.008121:0.003558:0.003861:0.007897:0.009062:0.008057:0.009062:0.005632:0.005409:0.009365:0.008312:0.005409:0.006509:0.013689:0.005297:0.006047:0.008057:0.007467:0.008312:0.003526:0.006461:0.006557:0.008727:0.008982:0.008823:0.003861:0.008982:0.004371:0.002521:0.008727:0.007722:0.007387:0.007977:0.006461:0.008903:0.007802:0.007802:0.008567:0.006382:0.008982:0.003861:0.007132:0.007977:0.008727:0.006461:0.006892:0.006047:0.007371:0.009094:0.005552:0.009062:0.009030:0.008121:0.005361:0.007722:0.004371 angiogram by the hospital in November 2012, which :@0.096314:0.516026:0.476378:0.516026:0.476378:0.505441:0.096314:0.505441:0.008121:0.008839:0.009397:0.003861:0.009158:0.009397:0.005377:0.008121:0.013545:0.006382:0.008647:0.007132:0.005201:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006047:0.008823:0.008982:0.006461:0.009062:0.003861:0.005201:0.007802:0.003861:0.006382:0.003366:0.007897:0.006461:0.011679:0.009062:0.007467:0.008344:0.013242:0.009158:0.008344:0.005265:0.005632:0.009062:0.009158:0.009158:0.009238:0.003701:0.005632:0.011535:0.009381:0.003861:0.007562:0.009238:0.004371 would have revealed coronary artery disease.:@0.095558:0.531467:0.414086:0.531467:0.414086:0.520883:0.095558:0.520883:0.011535:0.009716:0.009030:0.004068:0.009573:0.006461:0.008823:0.007897:0.007467:0.008057:0.006047:0.005377:0.007977:0.007307:0.008057:0.007722:0.003861:0.007897:0.008982:0.006461:0.007371:0.009349:0.005552:0.009126:0.009030:0.008121:0.005552:0.007530:0.005297:0.008121:0.005552:0.005217:0.008344:0.005552:0.007514:0.005201:0.009397:0.003622:0.006765:0.007929:0.007897:0.006557:0.008153:0.003462 Esmee Polmear, aged 7, was referred by her GP to the :@0.097153:0.553682:0.484859:0.553682:0.484859:0.543098:0.097153:0.543098:0.007722:0.006557:0.013178:0.008057:0.007977:0.004371:0.002521:0.008392:0.008903:0.003861:0.012763:0.007977:0.007642:0.005201:0.003271:0.006461:0.007897:0.008982:0.007977:0.008982:0.006461:0.008599:0.003462:0.005664:0.012349:0.008647:0.007227:0.005632:0.005377:0.008057:0.004994:0.007945:0.005377:0.005377:0.008153:0.009158:0.004371:0.002521:0.008647:0.007052:0.005632:0.008727:0.008057:0.005377:0.005632:0.010657:0.008727:0.005201:0.005409:0.009126:0.004866:0.005409:0.008695:0.008057:0.004371 trust following episodes of not being able to breathe and :@0.095894:0.569063:0.507787:0.569063:0.507787:0.558478:0.095894:0.558478:0.005409:0.005552:0.009030:0.006765:0.005409:0.004946:0.004994:0.009541:0.003861:0.004036:0.009349:0.011726:0.003861:0.009238:0.009397:0.006142:0.008057:0.009381:0.003638:0.006765:0.009014:0.009397:0.007977:0.006765:0.005488:0.009349:0.004754:0.005632:0.009030:0.009110:0.005409:0.005504:0.008982:0.007977:0.003861:0.008488:0.008982:0.006047:0.008121:0.009014:0.003861:0.008057:0.005201:0.005409:0.009126:0.006047:0.009381:0.005313:0.008153:0.008121:0.005153:0.009030:0.008009:0.005712:0.007642:0.008488:0.008823:0.004371 turning blue. The reviewing paediatrician concluded in :@0.095894:0.584444:0.487636:0.584444:0.487636:0.573859:0.095894:0.573859:0.005409:0.009030:0.005552:0.009030:0.003861:0.009030:0.009397:0.004371:0.002425:0.008982:0.003861:0.008392:0.008057:0.003271:0.006461:0.008360:0.008855:0.008344:0.006270:0.005552:0.008137:0.007642:0.003861:0.008057:0.011344:0.003861:0.008823:0.009397:0.006733:0.009381:0.007834:0.008344:0.009206:0.003861:0.007897:0.005409:0.005552:0.003654:0.007371:0.003861:0.007834:0.009030:0.006334:0.007371:0.009094:0.009030:0.007179:0.003861:0.009030:0.009110:0.008344:0.009126:0.004371:0.002425:0.003111:0.007387:0.004371 January 2015 that her symptoms were likely to be related :@0.095558:0.599885:0.509397:0.599885:0.509397:0.589300:0.095558:0.589300:0.005696:0.008121:0.009365:0.009238:0.008121:0.005552:0.007913:0.005201:0.008982:0.009062:0.008903:0.008903:0.006047:0.005409:0.009030:0.008312:0.005409:0.006095:0.008727:0.008057:0.005377:0.005297:0.006765:0.007722:0.013481:0.009381:0.005233:0.009349:0.013497:0.006765:0.004818:0.011838:0.008567:0.005552:0.008631:0.006047:0.003861:0.003606:0.007722:0.008153:0.003861:0.007483:0.004866:0.005409:0.009126:0.005632:0.008823:0.007722:0.006047:0.005297:0.007897:0.003861:0.007562:0.005121:0.007977:0.008982:0.004371 to exertion, with nothing to suggest an underlying heart :@0.095894:0.615562:0.502729:0.615562:0.502729:0.604978:0.095894:0.604978:0.005121:0.008982:0.005712:0.008344:0.007530:0.008344:0.005552:0.005409:0.003861:0.009349:0.009030:0.003462:0.005632:0.011838:0.003861:0.005632:0.009238:0.004371:0.002521:0.008823:0.009158:0.005409:0.008775:0.003861:0.008727:0.009397:0.005887:0.005409:0.009126:0.005201:0.006765:0.008775:0.009397:0.009397:0.008073:0.006765:0.005409:0.005121:0.007642:0.008488:0.004371:0.002425:0.009030:0.008599:0.009158:0.008153:0.005377:0.003861:0.007483:0.003861:0.008727:0.009158:0.004371:0.002521:0.009030:0.008105:0.008121:0.005313:0.005409:0.004371 problem. However, on 1 July 2015, over five months :@0.096734:0.630944:0.473559:0.630944:0.473559:0.620360:0.096734:0.620360:0.009158:0.005377:0.009062:0.009158:0.003861:0.007977:0.013354:0.003462:0.004371:0.003159:0.010993:0.009158:0.011344:0.008153:0.007467:0.008153:0.005552:0.003271:0.006461:0.008567:0.008312:0.004371:0.003685:0.008599:0.003159:0.005696:0.009030:0.003861:0.007722:0.005089:0.009062:0.009158:0.009158:0.009238:0.003701:0.006461:0.008982:0.007387:0.008057:0.005377:0.005201:0.004786:0.003861:0.007387:0.008153:0.006461:0.013513:0.009158:0.009030:0.005153:0.008823:0.006765:0.004371 :@0.264860:0.630944:0.269232:0.630944:0.269232:0.620360:0.264860:0.620360:0.004371 later, Esmee felt unwell on a school trip. Her parents :@0.096734:0.646326:0.472330:0.646326:0.472330:0.635742:0.096734:0.635742:0.003606:0.007562:0.005042:0.007722:0.005121:0.003191:0.004371:0.003271:0.007802:0.006557:0.013178:0.008057:0.007977:0.005632:0.004994:0.008344:0.003861:0.005409:0.006031:0.009030:0.009030:0.011328:0.008344:0.003861:0.003861:0.006525:0.008567:0.008312:0.006461:0.006892:0.006047:0.006557:0.006972:0.008727:0.008982:0.008982:0.003861:0.005887:0.005201:0.005552:0.003685:0.009381:0.003207:0.004371:0.003271:0.010753:0.007802:0.005201:0.005632:0.009381:0.007658:0.005377:0.008153:0.008727:0.005409:0.006509:0.004371 agreed to bring her back but when they reached her :@0.096314:0.661707:0.474782:0.661707:0.474782:0.651122:0.096314:0.651122:0.007802:0.009062:0.005297:0.007977:0.007977:0.009062:0.006047:0.005409:0.009126:0.006047:0.008903:0.005201:0.003606:0.008488:0.008823:0.004371:0.002521:0.008727:0.008057:0.005377:0.005632:0.009381:0.008121:0.007371:0.007929:0.005488:0.009381:0.008679:0.005409:0.004371:0.011886:0.009317:0.008567:0.009317:0.006047:0.005409:0.009030:0.008344:0.007722:0.005775:0.005377:0.008057:0.007897:0.007132:0.008727:0.008153:0.009062:0.004371:0.002425:0.008647:0.007897:0.005297:0.004371 she was lying on the ground with a staff member giving :@0.096314:0.677088:0.498969:0.677088:0.498969:0.666503:0.096314:0.666503:0.006461:0.008567:0.007977:0.004786:0.012349:0.008647:0.007227:0.005712:0.003606:0.007307:0.003606:0.008488:0.008823:0.006047:0.008567:0.008312:0.006047:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006047:0.009158:0.005377:0.008982:0.008727:0.008647:0.009062:0.005712:0.011918:0.004036:0.005632:0.009397:0.006047:0.006892:0.006461:0.006765:0.005409:0.008312:0.004994:0.004994:0.005791:0.013737:0.008344:0.013737:0.009110:0.008344:0.005552:0.005249:0.008903:0.003606:0.007227:0.003606:0.008488:0.008903:0.004371 mouth-to-mouth resuscitation. She was not breathing :@0.096734:0.692529:0.483993:0.692529:0.483993:0.681944:0.096734:0.681944:0.013737:0.009349:0.008743:0.005409:0.008695:0.006382:0.005409:0.009030:0.006382:0.013513:0.009158:0.009030:0.005153:0.009030:0.006749:0.005552:0.008344:0.006589:0.009030:0.006589:0.007371:0.003861:0.005233:0.008121:0.005233:0.003861:0.009349:0.009030:0.003287:0.004371:0.002521:0.008153:0.008727:0.008057:0.004866:0.012093:0.008567:0.007132:0.006047:0.008823:0.008982:0.005201:0.006047:0.009062:0.005377:0.008057:0.007897:0.005201:0.008823:0.003861:0.008647:0.009158:0.004371 and died shortly afterwards. Both parents suffered post­:@0.096314:0.708206:0.496927:0.708206:0.496927:0.697622:0.096314:0.697622:0.007802:0.008647:0.008982:0.006047:0.008903:0.003861:0.007722:0.008903:0.006047:0.006765:0.008855:0.009349:0.005552:0.005169:0.003861:0.007722:0.005121:0.008312:0.004994:0.005584:0.008344:0.005760:0.011758:0.008312:0.005552:0.009652:0.006765:0.003462:0.004371:0.002952:0.008727:0.008903:0.005201:0.008647:0.004371:0.002425:0.009381:0.007754:0.005552:0.008137:0.008823:0.005409:0.006765:0.005456:0.006765:0.008775:0.004994:0.004994:0.007977:0.005552:0.008137:0.009397:0.006733:0.009158:0.009158:0.006765:0.005153:0.006382 traumatic stress disorder. The trust admitted negligence :@0.095894:0.723587:0.495310:0.723587:0.495310:0.713003:0.095894:0.713003:0.005409:0.005552:0.008360:0.009238:0.013944:0.008312:0.005409:0.003861:0.007690:0.005201:0.006557:0.005121:0.005297:0.007977:0.006461:0.006461:0.005712:0.008823:0.003861:0.006302:0.008823:0.005297:0.008903:0.007897:0.005297:0.003271:0.006382:0.008360:0.008855:0.008344:0.005504:0.005409:0.005552:0.009030:0.006765:0.005409:0.005281:0.008121:0.009397:0.013386:0.003861:0.005409:0.005169:0.008344:0.009206:0.006461:0.009030:0.008344:0.009158:0.003861:0.003861:0.009078:0.008153:0.009030:0.007100:0.008153:0.004371 by failing to diagnose Esmee's underlying condition.:@0.096734:0.738968:0.464146:0.738968:0.464146:0.728383:0.096734:0.728383:0.008647:0.007052:0.004866:0.004994:0.007850:0.003861:0.003861:0.003622:0.009030:0.009110:0.006047:0.005409:0.009126:0.005632:0.009397:0.003861:0.007897:0.009158:0.009030:0.009030:0.006765:0.008105:0.006461:0.007802:0.006557:0.013178:0.008057:0.007977:0.003669:0.006414:0.005632:0.008823:0.008823:0.009397:0.007977:0.005552:0.003685:0.007722:0.003622:0.009030:0.009110:0.006047:0.007371:0.008998:0.009030:0.009397:0.003861:0.005169:0.003861:0.009349:0.009030:0.003462 Ms Purchase visited her GP in January 2013 with acute :@0.097153:0.761248:0.489614:0.761248:0.489614:0.750664:0.097153:0.750664:0.013354:0.006382:0.006047:0.008647:0.008823:0.005377:0.007132:0.008727:0.007897:0.006765:0.007929:0.005201:0.007307:0.003861:0.006557:0.003861:0.005121:0.008057:0.009158:0.006461:0.008727:0.008057:0.005377:0.006047:0.010657:0.008647:0.005712:0.003271:0.007562:0.005632:0.005967:0.008121:0.009349:0.009238:0.008121:0.005728:0.007897:0.005297:0.008982:0.009062:0.008903:0.008903:0.005201:0.011918:0.004036:0.005712:0.009397:0.006461:0.008121:0.006988:0.009030:0.005153:0.008153:0.004371 sinusitis. Afterwards she continued to feel unwell :@0.096314:0.776629:0.449845:0.776629:0.449845:0.766045:0.096314:0.766045:0.006765:0.003654:0.008727:0.008823:0.006557:0.003861:0.005201:0.003861:0.006461:0.003462:0.005935:0.010753:0.004994:0.005760:0.008727:0.005791:0.011918:0.008488:0.005791:0.009748:0.007052:0.005632:0.006461:0.008567:0.007897:0.006047:0.007371:0.009349:0.009030:0.005153:0.003861:0.009030:0.008855:0.008344:0.009206:0.006047:0.005121:0.008982:0.005201:0.004994:0.008105:0.008153:0.003861:0.006717:0.009030:0.008695:0.011248:0.008344:0.003669:0.003861:0.004371 and by 4 April she was weak, dizzy and had difficulty :@0.096314:0.792010:0.479154:0.792010:0.479154:0.781425:0.096314:0.781425:0.007802:0.008647:0.008982:0.006382:0.008647:0.007132:0.005201:0.008903:0.004371:0.010291:0.009190:0.005552:0.003861:0.003861:0.006382:0.006557:0.008727:0.008057:0.004866:0.012093:0.008567:0.007132:0.004866:0.012253:0.008903:0.008567:0.008488:0.003701:0.006461:0.009397:0.003861:0.006972:0.007211:0.007722:0.005137:0.007802:0.008567:0.008982:0.006461:0.008488:0.007642:0.008903:0.006382:0.009397:0.003861:0.004994:0.004994:0.003861:0.007371:0.009030:0.003861:0.005409:0.007722:0.004371 breathing. Her mother took her to an out-of-hours GP, :@0.096734:0.807392:0.488444:0.807392:0.488444:0.796807:0.096734:0.796807:0.009381:0.005552:0.008153:0.008121:0.005233:0.009030:0.003654:0.008823:0.009397:0.003191:0.004371:0.003271:0.010753:0.007802:0.005201:0.005712:0.013737:0.009349:0.005217:0.009030:0.008344:0.005552:0.005201:0.005409:0.009349:0.009349:0.008137:0.005632:0.008727:0.008057:0.005377:0.005201:0.005409:0.009126:0.005201:0.007642:0.008488:0.006461:0.009158:0.009030:0.005409:0.006126:0.009349:0.004994:0.006142:0.009030:0.009349:0.008743:0.005552:0.006765:0.005903:0.009493:0.007722:0.002936:0.004371 who made a diagnosis of respiratory tract infection with :@0.095558:0.822772:0.499218:0.822772:0.499218:0.812188:0.095558:0.812188:0.012093:0.009493:0.009828:0.006047:0.013434:0.007897:0.009397:0.007977:0.005632:0.006892:0.006047:0.009397:0.003861:0.007897:0.009158:0.009030:0.009110:0.006765:0.003861:0.006589:0.005201:0.009349:0.005185:0.005632:0.005552:0.008057:0.006765:0.009190:0.003861:0.005377:0.007897:0.005409:0.009126:0.005552:0.007467:0.004786:0.005409:0.005552:0.008360:0.007371:0.005409:0.006190:0.003861:0.009030:0.004738:0.008344:0.007195:0.005409:0.003861:0.009030:0.009030:0.005584:0.011535:0.003861:0.005680:0.009030:0.004371 pleuritic pain, oral thrush and depression. He prescribed :@0.096734:0.838450:0.497267:0.838450:0.497267:0.827866:0.096734:0.827866:0.009381:0.003638:0.008153:0.009030:0.005329:0.003861:0.005201:0.003861:0.007132:0.005712:0.009381:0.007913:0.003861:0.009030:0.003239:0.006461:0.008823:0.005201:0.007722:0.003606:0.006047:0.005409:0.009030:0.005297:0.009030:0.006589:0.009030:0.006414:0.007802:0.008567:0.008982:0.006047:0.009397:0.007977:0.009381:0.005313:0.008153:0.006765:0.006509:0.003861:0.009078:0.008823:0.003462:0.004371:0.003590:0.009987:0.007387:0.006461:0.009062:0.005297:0.007977:0.006557:0.006972:0.005377:0.003861:0.008727:0.008057:0.008982:0.004371 antibiotics and antidepressants. However, her condition :@0.096314:0.853891:0.494119:0.853891:0.494119:0.843307:0.096314:0.843307:0.008121:0.008839:0.005409:0.003861:0.009206:0.003861:0.009349:0.005409:0.003861:0.007163:0.006765:0.005584:0.007802:0.008567:0.008982:0.006047:0.008121:0.008839:0.005409:0.003861:0.009126:0.008344:0.009381:0.005552:0.008344:0.006765:0.006765:0.008121:0.009030:0.005409:0.006765:0.003462:0.004371:0.003255:0.010993:0.009158:0.011344:0.008153:0.007467:0.008153:0.005552:0.003271:0.004371:0.002521:0.008727:0.008057:0.005377:0.005632:0.007371:0.008918:0.008823:0.009158:0.003861:0.005121:0.003861:0.008982:0.008823:0.004371 remained unaltered. On 7 April, three days later, her :@0.096734:0.869272:0.471963:0.869272:0.471963:0.858687:0.096734:0.858687:0.005377:0.008057:0.013354:0.007897:0.003861:0.008647:0.008153:0.009158:0.004371:0.002521:0.009030:0.008775:0.008121:0.003861:0.005153:0.008344:0.005552:0.008105:0.009397:0.003462:0.004371:0.002425:0.011503:0.008647:0.006047:0.007642:0.005632:0.010578:0.009381:0.005728:0.003861:0.004036:0.003462:0.006446:0.005409:0.009030:0.005377:0.008344:0.008121:0.005712:0.008982:0.007802:0.007307:0.006461:0.006047:0.003861:0.007483:0.005042:0.007802:0.005201:0.003271:0.004371:0.002521:0.008567:0.007897:0.005297:0.004371 mother returned home to find Ms Purchase lying :@0.096734:0.884653:0.447330:0.884653:0.447330:0.874068:0.096734:0.874068:0.013737:0.009110:0.005409:0.009030:0.008073:0.005552:0.005951:0.005552:0.008137:0.005409:0.008615:0.005377:0.008823:0.008153:0.009158:0.004371:0.002521:0.008823:0.009062:0.013434:0.008153:0.005712:0.005121:0.008982:0.005201:0.004994:0.003861:0.009030:0.009158:0.004371:0.002425:0.013354:0.006382:0.006461:0.008647:0.008823:0.005377:0.007132:0.008727:0.007897:0.006765:0.007929:0.006047:0.003606:0.007132:0.003606:0.008312:0.008727:0.004371 motionless on her bed, staring at the ceiling, although :@0.096734:0.900033:0.486896:0.900033:0.486896:0.889449:0.096734:0.889449:0.013513:0.009158:0.005409:0.003654:0.009349:0.008711:0.003861:0.008153:0.006557:0.006765:0.005488:0.008567:0.008392:0.004371:0.002425:0.008727:0.008057:0.005377:0.005632:0.009062:0.007977:0.009062:0.003462:0.006701:0.006765:0.005073:0.007897:0.005377:0.003861:0.008647:0.009158:0.006461:0.007802:0.005121:0.005201:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.005632:0.007371:0.008073:0.003861:0.003861:0.003861:0.009030:0.009397:0.003462:0.006334:0.008121:0.003638:0.005409:0.009030:0.009078:0.009030:0.009190:0.009030:0.004371 she looked alive. She was then joined by her other :@0.096314:0.915415:0.459418:0.915415:0.459418:0.904831:0.096314:0.904831:0.006461:0.008567:0.007977:0.006047:0.003861:0.008903:0.009158:0.007642:0.008057:0.009158:0.006047:0.007897:0.003861:0.003861:0.007227:0.008057:0.003462:0.006701:0.008232:0.008727:0.008057:0.005201:0.012093:0.008567:0.007132:0.005297:0.005409:0.008695:0.008057:0.008823:0.005297:0.003861:0.009349:0.003861:0.009030:0.008073:0.009397:0.004371:0.002441:0.008647:0.007052:0.005632:0.008727:0.008057:0.005377:0.005297:0.009158:0.005409:0.008775:0.008344:0.005345:0.004371 daughter and ex-husband. A 999 operator advised the :@0.096314:0.931094:0.489189:0.931094:0.489189:0.920510:0.096314:0.920510:0.009397:0.008328:0.009030:0.009397:0.009030:0.005409:0.008344:0.005552:0.005297:0.007802:0.008567:0.008982:0.006461:0.008344:0.007323:0.006158:0.009030:0.008855:0.006765:0.009190:0.008121:0.008839:0.009397:0.003462:0.005951:0.011344:0.005632:0.008903:0.008903:0.008823:0.006047:0.009349:0.009206:0.008344:0.005552:0.008121:0.005409:0.009349:0.005552:0.005201:0.007802:0.009062:0.007387:0.003861:0.006302:0.008057:0.009062:0.006047:0.005409:0.008695:0.008057:0.004371 family to give cardio-pulmonary resuscitation pending :@0.095894:0.946535:0.482419:0.946535:0.482419:0.935951:0.095894:0.935951:0.004994:0.008121:0.013737:0.003861:0.003861:0.007722:0.005313:0.005121:0.008982:0.005632:0.008903:0.003861:0.007132:0.007897:0.005632:0.007371:0.007913:0.005552:0.009222:0.003861:0.009349:0.006382:0.009381:0.009030:0.003861:0.013737:0.009349:0.009030:0.008121:0.005552:0.007722:0.005552:0.005377:0.008153:0.006765:0.008775:0.006557:0.007371:0.003622:0.005409:0.007865:0.005409:0.003654:0.009349:0.008791:0.004371:0.002521:0.009158:0.008057:0.008727:0.008982:0.003861:0.008567:0.009062:0.004371 arrival of an ambulance. This proved unsuccessful, and:@0.096314:0.961917:0.484163:0.961917:0.484163:0.951333:0.096314:0.951333:0.007802:0.005377:0.005377:0.003861:0.007227:0.007802:0.003861:0.006302:0.009349:0.004754:0.005201:0.007642:0.008488:0.006461:0.008121:0.013737:0.009381:0.009238:0.003861:0.008121:0.009030:0.007371:0.008344:0.003462:0.006414:0.008360:0.008855:0.003861:0.006765:0.005584:0.008903:0.005201:0.008903:0.007307:0.007897:0.008982:0.004371:0.002425:0.009030:0.009030:0.006956:0.009030:0.007371:0.007371:0.008344:0.006765:0.006765:0.004994:0.009030:0.003861:0.003462:0.006318:0.007642:0.008488:0.009397 paramedics could not achieve any improvement. Ms :@0.536905:0.102738:0.911672:0.102738:0.911672:0.092153:0.536905:0.092153:0.009381:0.007913:0.005552:0.008121:0.013449:0.008344:0.009206:0.003861:0.007371:0.006573:0.005632:0.007052:0.008982:0.008727:0.003861:0.008903:0.004371:0.002425:0.008823:0.008982:0.005201:0.005632:0.008121:0.007084:0.009030:0.003861:0.008105:0.007642:0.008137:0.005632:0.008121:0.008839:0.007722:0.005552:0.003861:0.013737:0.009190:0.005552:0.009349:0.007642:0.008105:0.013737:0.008344:0.008823:0.005409:0.003462:0.004371:0.003223:0.013178:0.006206:0.004371 Purchase died. Her mother sustained post-traumatic :@0.537241:0.118120:0.910987:0.118120:0.910987:0.107535:0.537241:0.107535:0.008647:0.008823:0.005377:0.007132:0.008727:0.007897:0.006765:0.007929:0.005632:0.009158:0.003861:0.007977:0.009158:0.003462:0.004371:0.003159:0.010753:0.007802:0.005201:0.005632:0.013737:0.009349:0.005217:0.009030:0.008344:0.005552:0.005201:0.006765:0.008855:0.006765:0.005409:0.007897:0.003861:0.008727:0.008344:0.009126:0.006382:0.009381:0.009174:0.006765:0.005409:0.006382:0.005409:0.005552:0.007929:0.009030:0.013561:0.008121:0.005409:0.003861:0.007371:0.004371 stress disorder, severe chronic anxiety and ongoing :@0.536485:0.133502:0.899988:0.133502:0.899988:0.122917:0.536485:0.122917:0.006557:0.005121:0.005297:0.007977:0.006461:0.006461:0.005632:0.008982:0.003861:0.006302:0.008903:0.005297:0.008982:0.007977:0.005297:0.003271:0.006461:0.006557:0.008057:0.007387:0.008057:0.005377:0.008057:0.005632:0.007371:0.009030:0.005552:0.009349:0.009030:0.003861:0.007371:0.005281:0.008121:0.008839:0.007323:0.003861:0.008344:0.005409:0.007722:0.005217:0.007802:0.008567:0.008982:0.006461:0.008982:0.008727:0.009158:0.009062:0.003861:0.008727:0.009158:0.004371 depression. She alleged that the GP had failed properly :@0.536485:0.149179:0.932998:0.149179:0.932998:0.138595:0.536485:0.138595:0.009397:0.007977:0.009381:0.005313:0.008153:0.006765:0.006509:0.003861:0.009078:0.008823:0.003462:0.006701:0.008232:0.008727:0.008057:0.006047:0.007897:0.003861:0.003526:0.008057:0.009062:0.008057:0.009062:0.006047:0.005409:0.009365:0.008312:0.005409:0.005010:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006047:0.010945:0.008934:0.005472:0.008488:0.007642:0.008903:0.006047:0.004994:0.007850:0.003861:0.003861:0.008057:0.009397:0.006637:0.009158:0.005297:0.008982:0.009062:0.007977:0.005297:0.003861:0.007227:0.004371 to assess and treat her daughter's symptoms.:@0.536065:0.164561:0.855566:0.164561:0.855566:0.153977:0.536065:0.153977:0.005409:0.009126:0.005632:0.007802:0.006461:0.006557:0.007977:0.006557:0.006557:0.005632:0.007802:0.008647:0.008982:0.006047:0.005409:0.005552:0.008344:0.008121:0.005233:0.006047:0.008727:0.008057:0.005377:0.005201:0.009397:0.007897:0.009030:0.009110:0.009030:0.005409:0.008073:0.005552:0.003669:0.006557:0.005712:0.006765:0.007514:0.013354:0.009158:0.005409:0.009030:0.013354:0.006765:0.003462 The Court reviewed the leading court decisions on :@0.536065:0.186833:0.898723:0.186833:0.898723:0.176249:0.536065:0.176249:0.008360:0.008775:0.008344:0.005600:0.010163:0.009573:0.009238:0.005791:0.005409:0.006174:0.005377:0.008344:0.007435:0.003861:0.008344:0.011216:0.008344:0.009126:0.005632:0.005409:0.009206:0.008344:0.006095:0.003861:0.007818:0.007802:0.009062:0.003861:0.008488:0.009062:0.006461:0.007371:0.009349:0.009030:0.005552:0.005409:0.005185:0.009397:0.007977:0.007371:0.003622:0.006765:0.003861:0.009030:0.009030:0.006589:0.005632:0.008392:0.008153:0.004371 secondary victims. On behalf of the claimants it was :@0.536485:0.202215:0.910821:0.202215:0.910821:0.191631:0.536485:0.191631:0.006765:0.008344:0.007371:0.009174:0.009030:0.009190:0.008121:0.005552:0.007722:0.004371:0.007642:0.003861:0.007371:0.005233:0.003861:0.013737:0.006589:0.003462:0.004371:0.002409:0.011248:0.008488:0.004371:0.002521:0.009381:0.008169:0.009030:0.008121:0.003861:0.004994:0.005648:0.009349:0.004754:0.005201:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.005632:0.007371:0.003861:0.007913:0.003861:0.013737:0.008121:0.009030:0.005409:0.006765:0.006063:0.003366:0.004707:0.004866:0.011918:0.008392:0.007052:0.004371 argued that the \event\ which caused the trauma to :@0.536485:0.217597:0.919341:0.217597:0.919341:0.207013:0.536485:0.207013:0.007897:0.005552:0.009142:0.008823:0.008153:0.009397:0.005887:0.005409:0.009365:0.008312:0.005409:0.004914:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.004371:0.002425:0.006557:0.008903:0.008153:0.008823:0.009652:0.005712:0.006637:0.006461:0.011758:0.009317:0.003861:0.007642:0.009317:0.006461:0.007132:0.007802:0.008823:0.006765:0.007929:0.009158:0.006047:0.005409:0.009030:0.008073:0.005297:0.005409:0.005552:0.008121:0.009301:0.013737:0.008121:0.005775:0.005121:0.008982:0.004371 secondary victims need not occur at the same time as :@0.536485:0.232979:0.922165:0.232979:0.922165:0.222395:0.536485:0.222395:0.006765:0.008344:0.007371:0.009174:0.009030:0.009190:0.008121:0.005552:0.007722:0.004371:0.007642:0.003861:0.007371:0.005409:0.003861:0.013737:0.006589:0.006047:0.008567:0.007977:0.007977:0.008982:0.006382:0.009030:0.009110:0.005409:0.005089:0.009349:0.007371:0.007371:0.008743:0.005552:0.005536:0.008121:0.005233:0.004786:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006047:0.006765:0.007674:0.013354:0.008057:0.005712:0.005409:0.003861:0.013481:0.008344:0.005504:0.007467:0.006302:0.004371 the original negligence. However, the Court concluded :@0.536065:0.248361:0.930424:0.248361:0.930424:0.237776:0.536065:0.237776:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006047:0.009062:0.005377:0.003861:0.008903:0.003861:0.008567:0.007802:0.003861:0.006717:0.009030:0.008105:0.009397:0.003861:0.003622:0.009397:0.008153:0.009030:0.007179:0.008344:0.003462:0.004371:0.003143:0.010993:0.009158:0.011344:0.008153:0.007467:0.008153:0.005552:0.003271:0.006047:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006047:0.010163:0.009573:0.009238:0.005791:0.005409:0.005345:0.007371:0.009094:0.009030:0.007004:0.003861:0.008823:0.009397:0.007977:0.009397:0.004371 that it was bound by its own previous decision in Taylor :@0.536065:0.263743:0.934987:0.263743:0.934987:0.253158:0.536065:0.253158:0.005409:0.009365:0.008312:0.005409:0.005760:0.003526:0.004962:0.004371:0.012173:0.008567:0.007132:0.006047:0.009062:0.008982:0.008823:0.008727:0.009158:0.004371:0.002425:0.008647:0.007052:0.005712:0.003446:0.004866:0.006126:0.005712:0.009349:0.011535:0.009030:0.006701:0.009062:0.005297:0.008057:0.007387:0.003861:0.008982:0.008823:0.006765:0.005488:0.009158:0.008057:0.007132:0.003861:0.006382:0.003861:0.008823:0.008727:0.004371:0.002521:0.003271:0.007562:0.006047:0.007977:0.007562:0.007227:0.003606:0.008727:0.005201:0.004371 v. A. Novo (2013), where a mother suffered an accident :@0.535645:0.279480:0.937918:0.279480:0.937918:0.268895:0.535645:0.268895:0.006461:0.002856:0.006382:0.010578:0.003462:0.004371:0.003414:0.011248:0.008727:0.007132:0.008727:0.005632:0.004818:0.009126:0.008903:0.009062:0.008982:0.005042:0.003462:0.005855:0.011758:0.009317:0.008567:0.005552:0.008727:0.006047:0.006797:0.006461:0.013737:0.009349:0.005217:0.009030:0.008344:0.005552:0.005201:0.006765:0.009030:0.004994:0.004738:0.008344:0.005345:0.008344:0.009397:0.005935:0.007642:0.008488:0.006461:0.008121:0.007371:0.007179:0.003861:0.009397:0.008153:0.009030:0.005409:0.004371 at work when shelving fell onto her. Three weeks later :@0.536485:0.294862:0.927781:0.294862:0.927781:0.284277:0.536485:0.284277:0.008121:0.005153:0.004371:0.012333:0.010083:0.005967:0.008392:0.004371:0.012093:0.009397:0.008647:0.009397:0.006047:0.006765:0.008599:0.008153:0.003861:0.007387:0.003861:0.008647:0.009158:0.006047:0.004611:0.007897:0.003606:0.003606:0.006461:0.009349:0.009030:0.005409:0.009349:0.005568:0.008232:0.007467:0.004962:0.003111:0.006461:0.008360:0.008775:0.005552:0.008137:0.008344:0.005169:0.012093:0.008727:0.008647:0.008232:0.007052:0.006047:0.003861:0.007642:0.005121:0.007897:0.005297:0.004371 she collapsed and died at home, witnessed by her :@0.536485:0.310243:0.896287:0.310243:0.896287:0.299659:0.536485:0.299659:0.006461:0.008567:0.007897:0.006047:0.007052:0.009062:0.003861:0.003861:0.007722:0.009062:0.006765:0.007929:0.009158:0.006461:0.007802:0.008647:0.008982:0.006382:0.008823:0.003606:0.007802:0.008823:0.006461:0.007722:0.005121:0.006047:0.009030:0.009349:0.013529:0.008344:0.003462:0.005488:0.011535:0.003861:0.005600:0.009030:0.008520:0.006765:0.006765:0.008552:0.009397:0.006557:0.008823:0.007307:0.005632:0.008567:0.007897:0.005297:0.004371 daughter, who was held unable to recover damages :@0.536485:0.325625:0.910901:0.325625:0.910901:0.315041:0.536485:0.315041:0.009397:0.007897:0.008823:0.009397:0.008663:0.005409:0.008105:0.005552:0.003271:0.005632:0.012253:0.009652:0.009908:0.004866:0.012093:0.008567:0.007132:0.006047:0.008488:0.007722:0.003606:0.008823:0.004371:0.002425:0.009030:0.008695:0.008121:0.009014:0.003861:0.008057:0.005632:0.005409:0.009126:0.005632:0.005552:0.007961:0.007371:0.008998:0.007467:0.008057:0.005377:0.005632:0.009397:0.008121:0.013306:0.008121:0.009094:0.008153:0.006765:0.004371 from her mother's employers for psychiatric trauma.:@0.536065:0.341007:0.904706:0.341007:0.904706:0.330423:0.536065:0.330423:0.004994:0.005552:0.009014:0.013513:0.004371:0.002425:0.008727:0.008057:0.005377:0.005632:0.013434:0.009062:0.005409:0.008775:0.008153:0.005377:0.003669:0.006573:0.005297:0.008153:0.013737:0.009190:0.003861:0.009158:0.007722:0.008153:0.005552:0.006765:0.004722:0.004994:0.009780:0.005552:0.005871:0.009381:0.006573:0.007722:0.007371:0.008839:0.003861:0.008121:0.005233:0.005552:0.003861:0.007371:0.004707:0.005409:0.005552:0.008121:0.009030:0.013737:0.008121:0.003462 The Court stated that for a secondary victim to recover :@0.536065:0.363279:0.931397:0.363279:0.931397:0.352695:0.536065:0.352695:0.008360:0.008775:0.008344:0.005600:0.010163:0.009573:0.009238:0.005791:0.005409:0.005760:0.006765:0.005073:0.008121:0.005058:0.008153:0.009158:0.005632:0.005409:0.009365:0.008312:0.005409:0.005345:0.004994:0.009541:0.005552:0.005361:0.006797:0.006461:0.006765:0.008344:0.007371:0.009094:0.009030:0.009190:0.008121:0.005552:0.007483:0.004371:0.007642:0.003861:0.007371:0.005217:0.003861:0.013737:0.005488:0.005409:0.009126:0.006047:0.005297:0.008057:0.007132:0.009062:0.007387:0.008057:0.005377:0.004371 against a defendant whose clinical negligence had caused :@0.536485:0.378660:0.953180:0.378660:0.953180:0.368076:0.536485:0.368076:0.008121:0.009605:0.008121:0.003861:0.009030:0.006765:0.005409:0.005105:0.006892:0.006047:0.009573:0.008344:0.005169:0.008344:0.009206:0.009397:0.008121:0.009269:0.005409:0.004914:0.011918:0.009317:0.009573:0.006972:0.008567:0.005632:0.007052:0.003861:0.003861:0.008567:0.003861:0.007052:0.007897:0.003861:0.004371:0.002425:0.009030:0.008344:0.009158:0.003861:0.003861:0.009078:0.008153:0.009030:0.007100:0.008153:0.006461:0.008488:0.007642:0.008903:0.006047:0.007052:0.007802:0.008823:0.006765:0.007929:0.009158:0.004371 the primary victim injury, the horrific event \cannot be a :@0.536065:0.394042:0.940332:0.394042:0.940332:0.383458:0.536065:0.383458:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006461:0.009158:0.005552:0.003685:0.013354:0.008121:0.005313:0.007722:0.004371:0.007467:0.003861:0.007371:0.005233:0.003861:0.013737:0.006334:0.003526:0.008567:0.003606:0.008488:0.005201:0.007307:0.003271:0.006382:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006047:0.009030:0.009110:0.005552:0.005552:0.003861:0.004994:0.003861:0.007371:0.005504:0.008344:0.007435:0.008344:0.009030:0.005137:0.006461:0.006254:0.007850:0.008488:0.009397:0.009493:0.009748:0.005632:0.006047:0.008567:0.007562:0.005632:0.006461:0.004371 separate event removed in time from the negligence\. :@0.536485:0.409721:0.926409:0.409721:0.926409:0.399136:0.536485:0.399136:0.006765:0.008344:0.009381:0.007929:0.005552:0.008121:0.005409:0.008121:0.005632:0.008344:0.007435:0.008344:0.009030:0.005137:0.006047:0.005377:0.007977:0.013274:0.008982:0.007387:0.008057:0.009062:0.004371:0.002425:0.003271:0.007642:0.006047:0.005409:0.003861:0.013481:0.008344:0.005169:0.004786:0.005552:0.009142:0.013513:0.006047:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006047:0.009030:0.008599:0.009573:0.003861:0.004036:0.009573:0.008344:0.009381:0.007371:0.008663:0.006254:0.003462:0.004371 Consequently, these claims could not succeed. However, :@0.536485:0.425103:0.941581:0.425103:0.941581:0.414518:0.536485:0.414518:0.009876:0.009349:0.008743:0.006765:0.008344:0.009397:0.009030:0.008344:0.009030:0.005409:0.003861:0.007722:0.003462:0.006222:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006765:0.008344:0.005456:0.007371:0.003861:0.007834:0.003861:0.013513:0.006765:0.005153:0.007132:0.008903:0.008727:0.003861:0.008823:0.004371:0.002521:0.009030:0.009030:0.005409:0.005169:0.006765:0.008775:0.007371:0.007371:0.008105:0.008344:0.009126:0.003462:0.004371:0.003255:0.011088:0.009062:0.011248:0.008057:0.007387:0.008057:0.005377:0.003462:0.004371 the Court of Appeal regarded this area of the law as :@0.536065:0.440544:0.913688:0.440544:0.913688:0.429960:0.536065:0.429960:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006047:0.010163:0.009573:0.009238:0.005791:0.005409:0.005345:0.009349:0.004754:0.004866:0.010291:0.009381:0.009381:0.008057:0.008121:0.003861:0.004371:0.002537:0.005377:0.007977:0.009062:0.007802:0.005297:0.009062:0.007977:0.009062:0.006047:0.005409:0.008775:0.003861:0.006557:0.005632:0.007897:0.005377:0.007977:0.007802:0.006047:0.009349:0.005185:0.004786:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006047:0.004036:0.008567:0.012014:0.005201:0.007307:0.006047:0.004371 being suitable for review by the Supreme Court and :@0.536905:0.455925:0.909678:0.455925:0.909678:0.445340:0.536905:0.445340:0.008903:0.007897:0.003606:0.008567:0.008903:0.006461:0.006765:0.008855:0.003861:0.005409:0.007865:0.009381:0.003638:0.008344:0.005089:0.004994:0.009541:0.005552:0.006126:0.005552:0.008344:0.007642:0.003861:0.008344:0.011535:0.005520:0.008823:0.007307:0.004866:0.005409:0.009030:0.008073:0.005712:0.008472:0.008743:0.009381:0.005552:0.008153:0.013513:0.008344:0.005504:0.010163:0.009573:0.009238:0.005791:0.005409:0.005760:0.007642:0.008488:0.008903:0.004371 therefore gave the claimants permission to appeal.:@0.536065:0.471307:0.895309:0.471307:0.895309:0.460722:0.536065:0.460722:0.005409:0.009030:0.008344:0.005552:0.008344:0.004994:0.009349:0.005552:0.008344:0.005616:0.009062:0.008121:0.007323:0.008153:0.005201:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006047:0.007371:0.003861:0.007913:0.003861:0.013737:0.008121:0.009030:0.005409:0.006765:0.006063:0.009062:0.008057:0.005377:0.013434:0.003861:0.006461:0.006765:0.003654:0.009062:0.008823:0.005632:0.005409:0.009126:0.005632:0.008121:0.009014:0.009381:0.007993:0.008121:0.003638:0.003462 Comment:@0.536485:0.493942:0.612377:0.493942:0.612377:0.482801:0.536485:0.482801:0.010479:0.009841:0.015031:0.015031:0.009086:0.009892:0.006533 These are all deeply tragic cases, and everyone will feel :@0.536065:0.515792:0.930392:0.515792:0.930392:0.505207:0.536065:0.505207:0.008360:0.008775:0.008344:0.006765:0.008073:0.006047:0.007562:0.005201:0.007802:0.006047:0.007227:0.003446:0.003446:0.006461:0.009158:0.008153:0.008344:0.008950:0.003861:0.007483:0.004786:0.005409:0.005552:0.008121:0.009397:0.003861:0.007626:0.005201:0.007371:0.007913:0.006765:0.008344:0.006557:0.003462:0.006366:0.007802:0.008567:0.008982:0.006461:0.008344:0.007435:0.008344:0.005345:0.007722:0.009078:0.009030:0.008009:0.004786:0.011535:0.003861:0.004084:0.003861:0.006126:0.004611:0.007977:0.007897:0.003861:0.004371 huge sympathy for the secondary victims. However, :@0.536905:0.531174:0.906503:0.531174:0.906503:0.520589:0.536905:0.520589:0.008823:0.008823:0.009397:0.007977:0.005632:0.006765:0.007722:0.013561:0.009381:0.008121:0.005409:0.008743:0.007722:0.005121:0.004994:0.009541:0.005552:0.004946:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.005632:0.006765:0.008344:0.007148:0.009349:0.009030:0.009397:0.008121:0.005552:0.007722:0.004371:0.007642:0.003861:0.007371:0.005409:0.003861:0.013737:0.006765:0.003462:0.004371:0.003175:0.010833:0.008982:0.011168:0.008057:0.007387:0.008057:0.005377:0.003462:0.004371 as the House of Lords made clear in the leading cases :@0.536485:0.546555:0.921766:0.546555:0.921766:0.535971:0.536485:0.535971:0.007722:0.006382:0.005201:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006461:0.010833:0.008903:0.008647:0.006382:0.007977:0.006047:0.009349:0.004754:0.006047:0.007052:0.008823:0.005201:0.008823:0.006382:0.006047:0.013434:0.007897:0.009158:0.008153:0.005712:0.007371:0.003861:0.008169:0.008121:0.005552:0.005552:0.003366:0.007977:0.005632:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006461:0.003861:0.007818:0.007802:0.009062:0.003861:0.008488:0.009062:0.006461:0.007052:0.007722:0.006557:0.007977:0.006557:0.004371 of Alcock, which dealt with the Hillsborough disaster, :@0.536485:0.561937:0.919309:0.561937:0.919309:0.551353:0.536485:0.551353:0.009349:0.004754:0.004786:0.010657:0.003861:0.007642:0.009748:0.007562:0.008232:0.003462:0.005696:0.011758:0.009317:0.003861:0.007642:0.009317:0.006461:0.009397:0.008153:0.008121:0.003861:0.005153:0.004866:0.011838:0.003861:0.005632:0.009238:0.006047:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006461:0.010913:0.003861:0.003861:0.003622:0.006557:0.008982:0.009062:0.005377:0.008982:0.008727:0.009062:0.008823:0.006461:0.008903:0.003861:0.006302:0.007642:0.006461:0.005121:0.007977:0.005297:0.003271:0.004371 there must be boundaries to recoverability by those :@0.536065:0.577377:0.906572:0.577377:0.906572:0.566793:0.536065:0.566793:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.005552:0.008137:0.006047:0.013737:0.008855:0.006765:0.005409:0.005552:0.008567:0.007562:0.006461:0.009381:0.009014:0.009030:0.008855:0.009397:0.007897:0.005552:0.003685:0.008344:0.006765:0.005121:0.005409:0.009030:0.006047:0.005552:0.008344:0.007100:0.009349:0.007355:0.008153:0.005552:0.007881:0.009158:0.003861:0.003861:0.003622:0.005409:0.007530:0.005712:0.008647:0.007052:0.004786:0.005409:0.008775:0.009158:0.006765:0.008344:0.004371 who are not primary victims. Without them, defendants :@0.535645:0.593056:0.939050:0.593056:0.939050:0.582472:0.535645:0.582472:0.012253:0.009652:0.009908:0.005297:0.007722:0.005297:0.007897:0.006461:0.008823:0.008982:0.005201:0.006047:0.009158:0.005552:0.003685:0.013434:0.008121:0.005313:0.007722:0.004196:0.007642:0.003861:0.007371:0.005409:0.003861:0.013737:0.006765:0.003462:0.005999:0.015444:0.004036:0.005712:0.009317:0.009748:0.009317:0.005632:0.004866:0.005409:0.009285:0.008344:0.014167:0.003462:0.006446:0.009397:0.008344:0.005185:0.008344:0.009030:0.009397:0.008121:0.009030:0.005409:0.006765:0.004371 would potentially be exposed to large numbers of :@0.535645:0.608437:0.896341:0.608437:0.896341:0.597852:0.535645:0.597852:0.011535:0.009716:0.009030:0.004068:0.009573:0.004371:0.002521:0.009381:0.009174:0.005409:0.008344:0.008759:0.005409:0.003861:0.007865:0.003861:0.003861:0.007483:0.006047:0.008567:0.007562:0.005632:0.007977:0.007132:0.009062:0.009158:0.006557:0.008153:0.009158:0.006047:0.005121:0.008982:0.006047:0.003861:0.007722:0.005297:0.009062:0.007977:0.006382:0.009030:0.009030:0.013513:0.009381:0.008169:0.005552:0.006765:0.005058:0.009349:0.004754:0.004371 claims arising from one act of negligence. Judges :@0.536485:0.623819:0.891277:0.623819:0.891277:0.613234:0.536485:0.613234:0.007371:0.003861:0.007834:0.003861:0.013434:0.006765:0.005249:0.007897:0.005377:0.003861:0.006382:0.003861:0.008647:0.009062:0.006047:0.004994:0.005552:0.009014:0.013513:0.006047:0.009158:0.009030:0.008009:0.005632:0.008121:0.007163:0.005409:0.005504:0.009349:0.004754:0.005632:0.009030:0.008344:0.009397:0.003861:0.003861:0.009174:0.008344:0.009030:0.007068:0.008344:0.003462:0.005999:0.005696:0.008839:0.009397:0.009078:0.008344:0.006765:0.004371 must determine where those boundaries should be :@0.536905:0.639201:0.904046:0.639201:0.904046:0.628616:0.536905:0.628616:0.013513:0.008823:0.006765:0.005153:0.005632:0.009397:0.008344:0.005409:0.008089:0.005552:0.013513:0.003861:0.009030:0.008105:0.005297:0.011758:0.009317:0.008567:0.005552:0.008727:0.005632:0.005409:0.008775:0.009158:0.006765:0.008344:0.006302:0.009381:0.009014:0.009030:0.008855:0.009397:0.007897:0.005552:0.003685:0.008344:0.006765:0.005552:0.006557:0.008727:0.008982:0.008823:0.003861:0.008982:0.004371:0.002425:0.008392:0.007387:0.004371 set. While it might well be foreseeable that failure to :@0.536485:0.654581:0.916150:0.654581:0.916150:0.643997:0.536485:0.643997:0.006557:0.007977:0.005121:0.003271:0.006047:0.015109:0.009238:0.003861:0.004036:0.008344:0.006605:0.003366:0.004707:0.005632:0.013737:0.003861:0.009397:0.008775:0.005409:0.004371:0.011806:0.008567:0.003861:0.004036:0.006382:0.008823:0.007722:0.005297:0.004994:0.009349:0.005552:0.008344:0.006765:0.008153:0.008344:0.008121:0.009381:0.003861:0.008073:0.005297:0.005409:0.009365:0.008312:0.005409:0.005345:0.004994:0.008121:0.003861:0.003861:0.009030:0.005552:0.008073:0.005712:0.005121:0.008982:0.004371 diagnose a heart condition could lead to the patient :@0.536485:0.669962:0.912098:0.669962:0.912098:0.659378:0.536485:0.659378:0.009397:0.003861:0.007897:0.009158:0.009030:0.009030:0.006765:0.008105:0.005712:0.006797:0.004371:0.002521:0.009030:0.008344:0.008121:0.005552:0.005233:0.005201:0.007371:0.009174:0.009030:0.009190:0.003861:0.005201:0.003861:0.009078:0.009030:0.005999:0.007132:0.008903:0.008727:0.003861:0.008823:0.004371:0.002521:0.003526:0.007802:0.007642:0.008823:0.006047:0.005409:0.009126:0.004786:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006461:0.009381:0.007913:0.005409:0.003861:0.008025:0.009030:0.005153:0.004371 collapsing and dying, witnessed by family members :@0.536485:0.685700:0.906530:0.685700:0.906530:0.675116:0.536485:0.675116:0.007371:0.008918:0.003861:0.003861:0.007818:0.009062:0.006765:0.003654:0.008823:0.009158:0.006461:0.007802:0.008647:0.008982:0.006047:0.009397:0.007483:0.003861:0.008823:0.009397:0.003462:0.005536:0.011535:0.003861:0.005600:0.009030:0.008520:0.006765:0.006765:0.008552:0.009397:0.006557:0.008647:0.007052:0.005201:0.004994:0.008121:0.013737:0.003861:0.003861:0.007722:0.006079:0.013434:0.008153:0.013434:0.009158:0.008344:0.005345:0.006765:0.004371 who suffer psychiatric trauma as a result, that does :@0.535645:0.701081:0.904780:0.701081:0.904780:0.690496:0.535645:0.690496:0.012253:0.009652:0.009908:0.005297:0.006765:0.009269:0.004994:0.005169:0.008344:0.005760:0.005632:0.009381:0.006573:0.007722:0.007371:0.008839:0.003861:0.008121:0.005233:0.005552:0.003861:0.007371:0.004707:0.005409:0.005552:0.008121:0.009030:0.013737:0.008121:0.006461:0.007467:0.006206:0.005632:0.006892:0.004371:0.002521:0.005297:0.008057:0.006557:0.008823:0.003861:0.005121:0.003462:0.005935:0.005409:0.009365:0.008312:0.005409:0.005760:0.008903:0.008903:0.007977:0.006461:0.004371 not necessarily mean that the witnesses can recover :@0.536905:0.716462:0.909614:0.716462:0.909614:0.705877:0.536905:0.705877:0.008727:0.008982:0.005201:0.006047:0.009030:0.008105:0.007371:0.008073:0.006765:0.006589:0.008121:0.005313:0.003861:0.003861:0.007483:0.005632:0.013274:0.008057:0.007897:0.008727:0.006047:0.005409:0.009365:0.008312:0.005409:0.004914:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.005201:0.011535:0.003861:0.005680:0.009030:0.008695:0.006765:0.007084:0.008344:0.007100:0.005297:0.007132:0.007802:0.008823:0.006461:0.005297:0.008057:0.007132:0.009062:0.007387:0.008057:0.005377:0.004371 damages. We must anticipate a definitive ruling from :@0.536485:0.731842:0.918942:0.731842:0.918942:0.721258:0.536485:0.721258:0.009397:0.008121:0.013737:0.008121:0.009158:0.008344:0.006765:0.003287:0.006047:0.015204:0.008567:0.006047:0.013513:0.008823:0.006765:0.005153:0.005632:0.008121:0.008759:0.005409:0.003861:0.007371:0.003861:0.009381:0.008121:0.005409:0.008344:0.005935:0.006892:0.006047:0.009397:0.008073:0.004994:0.003861:0.009030:0.003861:0.005201:0.003861:0.007642:0.008153:0.006461:0.005297:0.008567:0.003861:0.003526:0.008488:0.008903:0.006047:0.004786:0.005552:0.008982:0.013354:0.004371 the Supreme Court, perhaps in 2023, which will have :@0.536065:0.747223:0.921729:0.747223:0.921729:0.736639:0.536065:0.736639:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006047:0.008472:0.008663:0.009381:0.005313:0.008344:0.013322:0.008153:0.006047:0.010243:0.009573:0.009238:0.005791:0.005409:0.003654:0.004371:0.002521:0.009381:0.007993:0.005552:0.008807:0.007897:0.009381:0.006573:0.006047:0.003271:0.007642:0.006461:0.009062:0.009158:0.008982:0.009062:0.003462:0.005775:0.011838:0.009397:0.004036:0.007642:0.009397:0.005632:0.011535:0.003861:0.003861:0.003861:0.004371:0.002409:0.008727:0.007722:0.007387:0.007977:0.004371 important implications for both relatives and the NHS.:@0.536905:0.762664:0.920064:0.762664:0.920064:0.752080:0.536905:0.752080:0.003861:0.013737:0.009381:0.009349:0.005552:0.005409:0.008121:0.009030:0.005409:0.005887:0.003861:0.013737:0.009014:0.003861:0.003861:0.007148:0.008121:0.005233:0.003861:0.009158:0.009030:0.006589:0.005201:0.004994:0.009541:0.005552:0.005696:0.008903:0.008823:0.005121:0.008647:0.004371:0.002425:0.005552:0.007961:0.003861:0.007818:0.005201:0.003861:0.007642:0.007897:0.006765:0.005488:0.007802:0.008647:0.008982:0.005632:0.005409:0.009030:0.008153:0.006461:0.010833:0.010418:0.007802:0.003462