Page   of :@0.786887:0.944662:0.854776:0.944662:0.854776:0.931348:0.786887:0.931348:0.009459:0.007554:0.008813:0.006924:0.004253:0.008365:0.004419:0.008813:0.005036:0.004253
2:@0.824055:0.944662:0.832562:0.944662:0.832562:0.931348:0.824055:0.931348:0.008507
139:@0.854973:0.944662:0.879861:0.944662:0.879861:0.931348:0.854973:0.931348:0.008191:0.008191:0.008507
 :@0.879556:0.944662:0.883809:0.944662:0.883809:0.931348:0.879556:0.931348:0.004253
 :@0.121066:0.958470:0.125319:0.958470:0.125319:0.945157:0.121066:0.945157:0.004253
Please find the papers attached. Could you please provide us with your son's email address as :@0.121066:0.102000:0.877986:0.102000:0.877986:0.086221:0.121066:0.086221:0.011332:0.005646:0.008812:0.008812:0.007561:0.008812:0.005041:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.013227:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.008812:0.008166:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.014498:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005884:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.003750:0.007561:0.005041:0.009437:0.015728:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.007561:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041
well too. :@0.121066:0.118511:0.196730:0.118511:0.196730:0.102732:0.121066:0.102732:0.014498:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005172:0.005041
Regards. :@0.121066:0.134546:0.197352:0.134546:0.197352:0.118768:0.121066:0.118768:0.013227:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.007561:0.005753:0.005041
36, :@0.121066:0.151022:0.151311:0.151022:0.151311:0.135243:0.121066:0.135243:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041
Simon Cordell’s Skeleton Argument (2) Pdf :@0.121066:0.167508:0.501874:0.167508:0.501874:0.151729:0.121066:0.151729:0.011332:0.005646:0.016998:0.010082:0.011332:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.008812:0.011332:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.006916:0.007561:0.005041:0.011332:0.011332:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.011332:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.010082:0.010707:0.016998:0.008812:0.011332:0.006916:0.005041:0.006916:0.009457:0.006916:0.005041:0.012582:0.010707:0.006872:0.005041
Page: :@0.121066:0.184019:0.174634:0.184019:0.174634:0.168240:0.121066:0.168240:0.012582:0.010082:0.010102:0.008822:0.006940:0.005041
820 :@0.174668:0.184019:0.209316:0.184019:0.209316:0.168240:0.174668:0.168240:0.010082:0.010082:0.009443:0.005041
R (McCann) v Manchester Crown Ct (HL(E))                                                      :@0.121066:0.200506:0.788786:0.200506:0.788786:0.184727:0.121066:0.184727:0.014498:0.005041:0.006916:0.018893:0.008812:0.014498:0.010082:0.011332:0.011332:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.005041:0.018893:0.010082:0.011332:0.008812:0.011332:0.008812:0.007561:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.010082:0.014498:0.011332:0.005041:0.014498:0.006916:0.005041:0.006916:0.015728:0.013227:0.006916:0.013227:0.006916:0.006916:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.004416:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005726:0.005041
Lord Hope of Craighead :@0.121066:0.216542:0.324097:0.216542:0.324097:0.200763:0.121066:0.200763:0.011977:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.013227:0.006916:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.010952:0.005041
This view as to the meaning of the phrase “criminal charge” is                             :@0.121066:0.233017:0.771092:0.233017:0.771092:0.217238:0.121066:0.217238:0.012582:0.010082:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.014498:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.015728:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.007561:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.006291:0.007561:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.005041:0.006563:0.005041
reinforced by the third criterion, which is the nature and degree of severity of the penalty. The :@0.121066:0.249527:0.883968:0.249527:0.883968:0.233748:0.121066:0.233748:0.006916:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.008186:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005656:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.012582:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041
formulation of this criterion in the early case of :@0.121066:0.266002:0.507462:0.266002:0.507462:0.250223:0.121066:0.250223:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.015728:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.009457:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.007561:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041
Engel v The Netherlands:@0.508175:0.266002:0.715578:0.266002:0.715578:0.250223:0.508175:0.250223:0.013227:0.011332:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.012582:0.011332:0.008812:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.005646:0.011332:0.008812:0.007561:0.005646:0.010082:0.011332:0.010082:0.007844
 (No 1) r EHRR :@0.715642:0.266002:0.849791:0.266002:0.849791:0.250223:0.715642:0.250223:0.005041:0.006916:0.014498:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.006916:0.005041:0.012582:0.014498:0.013227:0.013227:0.005041
647, 678-679, para 82 is instructiv  :@0.121066:0.282489:0.419270:0.282489:0.419270:0.266710:0.121066:0.266710:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010132:0.006923:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.016057:0.005041
e::@0.398484:0.282489:0.414020:0.282489:0.414020:0.266710:0.398484:0.266710:0.008822:0.006714
 :@0.121066:0.298525:0.126107:0.298525:0.126107:0.282746:0.121066:0.282746:0.005041
“['Supervision by the court] would generally prove to be illusory if it did not also take into :@0.121066:0.315035:0.855376:0.315035:0.855376:0.299256:0.121066:0.299256:0.008812:0.006916:0.003750:0.011332:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.005646:0.007561:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.005646:0.006291:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.007561:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.011080:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.006936:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041
consideration the degree of severity of the penalty that the person concerned risks incurring. :@0.121066:0.331510:0.867626:0.331510:0.867626:0.315731:0.121066:0.315731:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.006916:0.005646:0.008166:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.006916:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041
In a society subscribing to the B rule of law, there belong to the ‘criminal’ sphere :@0.121066:0.347997:0.781345:0.347997:0.781345:0.332218:0.121066:0.332218:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.007561:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.008166:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.013227:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.008812:0.014498:0.005041:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.006916:0.005041:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.008186:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041
deprivations of liberty liable to be imposed as a punishment, except those which by their :@0.121066:0.364472:0.840089:0.364472:0.840089:0.348693:0.121066:0.348693:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.015728:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.007561:0.010082:0.015728:0.008812:0.010875:0.005646:0.005041:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.009437:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.008812:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.005646:0.009437:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.006916:0.005041
nature, duration or manner of execution cannot be appreciably detrimental. The seriousness :@0.121066:0.380544:0.861960:0.380544:0.861960:0.364765:0.121066:0.364765:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.015728:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005041:0.012582:0.010082:0.008186:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.010082:0.008812:0.008166:0.007561:0.005041
of what is at stake, the traditions of the contracting states and the importance attached by the :@0.121066:0.397019:0.870065:0.397019:0.870065:0.381240:0.121066:0.381240:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.007561:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.006916:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.007561:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.009437:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.015728:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.006291:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041
Convention to respect for the physical liberty of the person all require that this should be so.” :@0.121066:0.413505:0.878295:0.413505:0.878295:0.397727:0.121066:0.397727:0.013227:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.007561:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.008812:0.009252:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.007561:0.010082:0.005041:0.010230:0.005041
 :@0.121066:0.429992:0.126107:0.429992:0.126107:0.414213:0.121066:0.414213:0.005041
The underlying idea is that proceedings do not lie within the criminal sphere for the purposes :@0.121066:0.446503:0.875812:0.446503:0.875812:0.430724:0.121066:0.430724:0.012582:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.014498:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041
of article 6 unless they are capable of resulting in the imposition of a penalty by way of :@0.121066:0.462539:0.829194:0.462539:0.829194:0.446760:0.121066:0.446760:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.007561:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.007561:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.015728:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010687:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041
punishment. In :@0.121066:0.479014:0.247099:0.479014:0.247099:0.463235:0.121066:0.463235:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.007561:0.010082:0.015728:0.008922:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041
B v Chief Constable of Avon and Somerset Constabulary:@0.247173:0.479014:0.717611:0.479014:0.717611:0.463235:0.247173:0.463235:0.013227:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.013227:0.011332:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.013227:0.010082:0.011332:0.007561:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.013227:0.008812:0.010082:0.011332:0.005041:0.010082:0.011332:0.010082:0.005041:0.011332:0.010082:0.015728:0.008812:0.007561:0.008166:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.013227:0.010082:0.011332:0.007561:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.011332:0.005646:0.010082:0.007561:0.008953
 [2001] 1 WLR :@0.718162:0.479014:0.847250:0.479014:0.847250:0.463235:0.718162:0.463235:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.010687:0.010082:0.006291:0.005041:0.010082:0.005041:0.018893:0.012582:0.013227:0.005041
340, 353, para 28 Lord Bingham of Cornhill CJ said that he was aware of no case in which :@0.121066:0.495489:0.857140:0.495489:0.857140:0.479710:0.121066:0.479710:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.011977:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.013227:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.015728:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.013227:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.013227:0.008166:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.015103:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.007561:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041
the European Court has held a proceeding to be criminal even though an adverse outcome for :@0.121066:0.512011:0.878433:0.512011:0.878433:0.496232:0.121066:0.496232:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.012582:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.013227:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008166:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.015728:0.008812:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041
the defendant cannot result in any penalty. I agree. Although there are other aspects of the :@0.121066:0.528486:0.850048:0.528486:0.850048:0.512707:0.121066:0.512707:0.005671:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.007561:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.005041:0.014498:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.010687:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041
procedure which suggest that in proceedings for the imposition of an anti-social behaviour :@0.121066:0.544522:0.855420:0.544522:0.855420:0.528743:0.121066:0.528743:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.007561:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.015728:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.006550:0.006973:0.007561:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.006291:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041
order the person Is not “charged with a criminal offence”, the critical question as 1 see it is :@0.121066:0.561009:0.857843:0.561009:0.857843:0.545230:0.121066:0.545230:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.006916:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.006916:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.011066:0.008812:0.007561:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.009437:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041
whether the making of such an order amounts to the imposition of a penalty. But it is first :@0.121066:0.577484:0.848067:0.577484:0.848067:0.561705:0.121066:0.561705:0.014498:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.015728:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.007561:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.015728:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.015728:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.013227:0.010687:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.006916:0.005646:0.006916:0.007561:0.005646:0.005041
necessary to consider whether either of the first two criteria are satisfied. :@0.121066:0.593994:0.713088:0.593994:0.713088:0.578215:0.121066:0.578215:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.007561:0.008166:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.006916:0.005646:0.006916:0.007561:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.014498:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.007561:0.006916:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.006126:0.005041
 :@0.121066:0.610469:0.126107:0.610469:0.126107:0.594690:0.121066:0.594690:0.005041
The first criterion: classification in domestic law :@0.121066:0.626505:0.541613:0.626505:0.541613:0.610726:0.121066:0.610726:0.013227:0.011332:0.008812:0.005041:0.006916:0.005646:0.008812:0.007561:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.011332:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.007561:0.007561:0.005646:0.006916:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.011332:0.005041:0.005646:0.011332:0.005041:0.011332:0.010082:0.016998:0.008812:0.007561:0.006916:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.014652:0.005041
A finding that the proceedings were classified as criminal in domestic law is likely to be :@0.121066:0.642992:0.836649:0.642992:0.836649:0.627213:0.121066:0.627213:0.014493:0.005041:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.007561:0.007561:0.005646:0.006916:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.009437:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.015728:0.008812:0.007561:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.008812:0.014498:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.005646:0.010687:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041
conclusive. But a finding that they are civil is of relative weight and serves only as a starting :@0.121066:0.659503:0.870690:0.659503:0.870690:0.643724:0.121066:0.643724:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005041:0.013227:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.009437:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010687:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.007561:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041
poin  :@0.121066:0.675978:0.175928:0.675978:0.175928:0.660199:0.121066:0.660199:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.013930:0.005041
t::@0.156983:0.675978:0.170628:0.675978:0.170628:0.660199:0.156983:0.660199:0.006931:0.006714
Benham v United Kingdom :@0.175928:0.675978:0.407608:0.675978:0.407608:0.660199:0.175928:0.660199:0.013227:0.008812:0.011332:0.011332:0.010082:0.015728:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.014498:0.011332:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.013227:0.005646:0.011332:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.015728:0.005041
22 EHRR 293, 323, para 56. In :@0.407944:0.675978:0.664325:0.675978:0.664325:0.660199:0.407944:0.660199:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.012582:0.014498:0.013227:0.013227:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041
Lauko v Slovakia:@0.664561:0.675978:0.808203:0.675978:0.808203:0.660199:0.664561:0.660199:0.012582:0.009457:0.011332:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.005118:0.011332:0.005646:0.009457:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082
 (1998) :@0.808311:0.675978:0.872552:0.675978:0.872552:0.660199:0.808311:0.660199:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041
33 EHRR 994, 1010-1011, para 57 the court observed that the criteria are alternative and ^ :@0.121066:0.692013:0.856539:0.692013:0.856539:0.676234:0.121066:0.676234:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.012582:0.014498:0.013227:0.013227:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.010183:0.006940:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.009457:0.005041
not cumulativ  see also :@0.121066:0.708500:0.320841:0.708500:0.320841:0.692721:0.121066:0.692721:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.015728:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.015983:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.007561:0.010082:0.005041
e::@0.232638:0.708500:0.248174:0.708500:0.248174:0.692721:0.232638:0.692721:0.008822:0.006714
Garyfallou AEBE v Greece:@0.320938:0.708500:0.547719:0.708500:0.547719:0.692721:0.320938:0.692721:0.014498:0.010687:0.007561:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.011332:0.005041:0.013227:0.013227:0.013227:0.013227:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.014498:0.007561:0.009437:0.008812:0.008812:0.008953
 (1997) EHRR 344. As it was put in :@0.547914:0.708500:0.842626:0.708500:0.842626:0.692721:0.547914:0.692721:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.012582:0.014498:0.013227:0.013227:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.014498:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.005646:0.005646:0.014498:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041
Ozturk v Germany 6 :@0.121066:0.725011:0.294252:0.725011:0.294252:0.709232:0.121066:0.709232:0.014498:0.007561:0.005646:0.011332:0.007561:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.014498:0.009437:0.007561:0.015728:0.010082:0.011332:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.005041
EHRR 409, 424, para 54, one criterion cannot be applied so as to divest :@0.294440:0.725011:0.877341:0.725011:0.877341:0.709232:0.294440:0.709232:0.012582:0.014498:0.013227:0.013227:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.010576:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.007561:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.009437:0.007561:0.005646:0.005041
an offence of a criminal character if that has been established under another criterion. But it :@0.121066:0.741486:0.864339:0.741486:0.864339:0.725707:0.121066:0.725707:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.006916:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.007561:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010687:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.013227:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041
was recognised in :@0.121066:0.757973:0.269672:0.757973:0.269672:0.742194:0.121066:0.742194:0.014498:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.007561:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041
Lauko v Slovakia:@0.269857:0.757973:0.414672:0.757973:0.414672:0.742194:0.269857:0.742194:0.012582:0.010082:0.011332:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.011332:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082
, at p ion, para 57, that a cumulative approach may be :@0.414867:0.757973:0.851774:0.757973:0.851774:0.742194:0.414867:0.742194:0.005041:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.015728:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.009437:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.015728:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041
adopted if the separate analysis of each of them does not lead to a clear conclusion as to the :@0.121066:0.774008:0.863129:0.774008:0.863129:0.758229:0.121066:0.758229:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.007561:0.006291:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.006190:0.010082:0.008812:0.015728:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.008166:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041
existence of a “criminal charge”. For the reasons already given, I consider that the position :@0.121066:0.790519:0.857524:0.790519:0.857524:0.774740:0.121066:0.774740:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.007561:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.005041:0.011332:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.007561:0.010082:0.010687:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.006291:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041
under domestic law is that the proceedings are classified as civil proceedings and not :@0.121066:0.806994:0.810240:0.806994:0.810240:0.791215:0.121066:0.791215:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.015728:0.008812:0.007561:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.008812:0.014498:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.008166:0.007561:0.005646:0.006916:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.008812:0.010687:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041
criminal. In their helpful written submissions which were developed before us in oral :@0.121066:0.823481:0.812602:0.823481:0.812602:0.807702:0.121066:0.807702:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.006916:0.009863:0.005646:0.005041:0.014498:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.015728:0.005646:0.007561:0.007561:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010687:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041
argument Liberty, to whom leave was given to intervene in these appeals, have contended :@0.121066:0.839956:0.850083:0.839956:0.850083:0.824177:0.121066:0.824177:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.015728:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.011977:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.010082:0.015728:0.005041:0.005646:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.008166:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.006291:0.007561:0.005041:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041
that the essential question is how domestic law classifies the conduct which is at issue, not :@0.121066:0.856027:0.853733:0.856027:0.853733:0.840248:0.121066:0.840248:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.007561:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.009437:0.007561:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.014498:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.015728:0.009437:0.007561:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.008812:0.014498:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.008166:0.007561:0.005646:0.006916:0.005646:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.006291:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.009437:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.007561:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041
the proceedings themselves, d hey submit that the conduct which requires to be demonstrated :@0.121066:0.872502:0.877855:0.872502:0.877855:0.856723:0.121066:0.856723:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010230:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.015728:0.007561:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.009437:0.007561:0.005041:0.005041:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.015728:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.010687:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.006916:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.015728:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.006916:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041
falls within the scope of the criminal law, and that for this reason the proceedings should be :@0.121066:0.888989:0.864460:0.888989:0.864460:0.873210:0.121066:0.873210:0.006916:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.014498:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.008812:0.014498:0.005041:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010687:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041
treated as criminal proceedings in domestic law for the purposes of the Convention. They :@0.121066:0.905470:0.847986:0.905470:0.847986:0.889691:0.121066:0.889691:0.005646:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.015728:0.008812:0.007561:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.008812:0.014498:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.009437:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.013227:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.006291:0.005646:0.010082:0.011171:0.005041:0.005041:0.012582:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041