Page :@0.778032:0.944662:0.815035:0.944662:0.815035:0.931348:0.778032:0.931348:0.009459:0.007554:0.008813:0.006924:0.004253
79:@0.815234:0.944662:0.831931:0.944662:0.831931:0.931348:0.815234:0.931348:0.008191:0.008507
 of :@0.832255:0.944662:0.854767:0.944662:0.854767:0.931348:0.832255:0.931348:0.003781:0.008813:0.005665:0.004253
139:@0.854351:0.944662:0.879854:0.944662:0.879854:0.931348:0.854351:0.931348:0.008183:0.008813:0.008507
 :@0.879556:0.944662:0.883809:0.944662:0.883809:0.931348:0.879556:0.931348:0.004253
 :@0.121066:0.958470:0.125319:0.958470:0.125319:0.945157:0.121066:0.945157:0.004253
behaviour orders in Scotland strongly suggests that its intention was that applications for :@0.121066:0.102000:0.841151:0.102000:0.841151:0.086221:0.121066:0.086221:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.011332:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.007561:0.005646:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.007561:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.009437:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.009437:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041
these orders which were made in England and Wales should be made by way of civil :@0.121066:0.118511:0.810522:0.118511:0.810522:0.102732:0.121066:0.102732:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.007561:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.007561:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.015728:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.012582:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.018893:0.008812:0.005646:0.009437:0.007561:0.005041:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.016373:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.007541:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041
proceedings also. The grounds on which these applications may be made in both jurisdictions :@0.121066:0.134546:0.879724:0.134546:0.879724:0.118768:0.121066:0.118768:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.007561:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.012582:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.009437:0.007561:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010747:0.007561:0.005041:0.015728:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010687:0.008812:0.005041:0.015728:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.006291:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.006916:0.005646:0.007561:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041
are similar, and the consequences of the making of an anti-social behaviour order are the :@0.121066:0.151022:0.840700:0.151022:0.840700:0.135243:0.121066:0.135243:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.007561:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.009437:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.015728:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.006399:0.006923:0.007561:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041
same. In neither jurisdiction does an anti-social behaviour order have them. character of a :@0.121066:0.167508:0.848662:0.167508:0.848662:0.151729:0.121066:0.151729:0.007561:0.008812:0.015728:0.008812:0.005041:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.006916:0.005646:0.007561:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.006234:0.006923:0.007561:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.015728:0.005041:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.009437:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041
punishment for an offence such as a fine or imprisonment. The fact that an anti-social :@0.121066:0.184019:0.816390:0.184019:0.816390:0.168240:0.121066:0.168240:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.007561:0.010082:0.015728:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.006916:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.007561:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.006916:0.006063:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.015728:0.010082:0.006916:0.005646:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.015728:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.005041:0.012582:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.006254:0.006940:0.007561:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041
behaviour order has been made against him does not appear on the person’s criminal record. :@0.121066:0.200506:0.869602:0.200506:0.869602:0.184727:0.121066:0.184727:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.015728:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.005646:0.015728:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.009437:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.007561:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041
On the contrary, the order is described in both section 1(4) and section 1:9(3) as a prohibition. :@0.121066:0.216542:0.883414:0.216542:0.883414:0.200763:0.121066:0.200763:0.014498:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.006916:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.007561:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.008166:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.004416:0.005041
In this respect it has the character of a civil injunction or, in Scotland, a civil interim interdict. :@0.121066:0.233017:0.882728:0.233017:0.882728:0.217238:0.121066:0.217238:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.007561:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.005925:0.005024:0.010082:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.011332:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005041
A criminal sanction is available in both jurisdictions if the person is convicted of having :@0.121066:0.249527:0.836695:0.249527:0.836695:0.233748:0.121066:0.233748:0.014498:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.006916:0.005646:0.007561:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.006291:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010687:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041
breached the order: see section 1 (Ro) for England and Wales and section 1 for Scotland. But :@0.121066:0.266002:0.876840:0.266002:0.876840:0.250223:0.121066:0.250223:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.007561:0.009437:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.005041:0.006916:0.013227:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.012582:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.018893:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005968:0.011332:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.013227:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041
the proceedings which must be brought in the event of a breach are separate proceedings. :@0.121066:0.282489:0.844417:0.282489:0.844417:0.266710:0.121066:0.266710:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.015728:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005646:0.007561:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010687:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.005041
Overall, the scheme is so similar in both jurisdictions that the intention of Parliament as to the :@0.121066:0.298525:0.881901:0.298525:0.881901:0.282746:0.121066:0.282746:0.014498:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.015728:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005646:0.007561:0.010082:0.005041:0.007561:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.006916:0.005646:0.007561:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.011332:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.015728:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041
nature of the proceedings under which the application was to be made can be taken, in the :@0.121066:0.315035:0.850738:0.315035:0.850738:0.299256:0.121066:0.299256:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005696:0.014498:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.015728:0.008812:0.010687:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.009437:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041
absence of any contrary indication, to have been the same. :@0.121066:0.331510:0.597096:0.331510:0.597096:0.315731:0.121066:0.315731:0.008812:0.010082:0.007561:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.006916:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.007561:0.008812:0.015728:0.008812:0.006399:0.005041
127, :@0.121066:0.347997:0.161393:0.347997:0.161393:0.332218:0.121066:0.332218:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041
Simon Cordell’s Skeleton Argument (2) Pdf :@0.121066:0.364472:0.501874:0.364472:0.501874:0.348693:0.121066:0.348693:0.011332:0.005646:0.016998:0.010082:0.011332:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.008812:0.011332:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.006916:0.007561:0.005041:0.011332:0.011332:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.011332:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.010082:0.010707:0.016998:0.008812:0.011332:0.006916:0.005041:0.006916:0.009457:0.006916:0.005041:0.012582:0.010707:0.006872:0.005041
79 :@0.121066:0.380544:0.146271:0.380544:0.146271:0.364765:0.121066:0.364765:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041
R (McCann) v Manchester Crown Ct (HL(E) :@0.121066:0.397019:0.515148:0.397019:0.515148:0.381240:0.121066:0.381240:0.014498:0.005041:0.006916:0.018893:0.008812:0.014498:0.010082:0.011332:0.011332:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.005041:0.018893:0.010082:0.011332:0.008812:0.011332:0.008812:0.007561:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.010082:0.014498:0.011332:0.005041:0.014498:0.006916:0.005041:0.006916:0.015728:0.013227:0.006916:0.013227:0.007424:0.005041
[2003] AC :@0.121066:0.413505:0.213096:0.413505:0.213096:0.397727:0.121066:0.397727:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.006311:0.005041:0.014498:0.013896:0.005041
Lord Hope of Craighead :@0.121066:0.429992:0.324097:0.429992:0.324097:0.414213:0.121066:0.414213:0.011977:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.013227:0.006916:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.010952:0.005041
The second point is that it would not be inconsistent with a finding that the proceedings under :@0.121066:0.446503:0.882143:0.446503:0.882143:0.430724:0.121066:0.430724:0.012582:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.007561:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.014498:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.009437:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041
section I(I) of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 were civil proceedings for your Lordships to :@0.121066:0.462539:0.874683:0.462539:0.874683:0.446760:0.121066:0.446760:0.007561:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.006916:0.006916:0.006916:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.013227:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.005646:0.007561:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.006311:0.005041:0.011977:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.007561:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041
hold that the standard of proof to be applied was that which is required in criminal :@0.121066:0.479014:0.789750:0.479014:0.789750:0.463235:0.121066:0.463235:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.007561:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.010905:0.010082:0.005646:0.006916:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041
proceedings. In :@0.121066:0.495489:0.250154:0.495489:0.250154:0.479710:0.121066:0.479710:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041
Constanda v M:@0.250332:0.495489:0.376577:0.495489:0.376577:0.479710:0.250332:0.479710:0.013227:0.010082:0.011332:0.007561:0.005646:0.010082:0.011332:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.017925
 r 997 SC 217 the ground on which the child had been :@0.376422:0.495489:0.817277:0.495489:0.817277:0.479710:0.376422:0.479710:0.005058:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.011332:0.013227:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.009437:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041
referred to a children’s hearing was that he was exposed to moral danger in terms of section 3 :@0.121066:0.512011:0.880248:0.512011:0.880248:0.496232:0.121066:0.496232:0.006916:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.006916:0.006916:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.010082:0.006916:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.008166:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.015728:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.015728:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.005041
2. (2.) (b) of the Social Work (Scotland) Act 1968. The Court of Session held that, as the :@0.121066:0.528486:0.841930:0.528486:0.841930:0.512707:0.121066:0.512707:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.006931:0.010082:0.005041:0.006916:0.005041:0.006988:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.009457:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.011332:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.018893:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.006916:0.011332:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.009457:0.006916:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.012582:0.010082:0.008812:0.005592:0.013227:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.011332:0.008812:0.007561:0.007561:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041
whole substratum of the ground of referral was that the child had performed certain acts :@0.121066:0.544522:0.833630:0.544522:0.833630:0.528743:0.121066:0.528743:0.014498:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.006916:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.015728:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.006916:0.006916:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.015728:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.006291:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041
which constituted criminal offences, the commission of these offences had to be proved to the :@0.121066:0.561009:0.882708:0.561009:0.882708:0.545230:0.121066:0.545230:0.014498:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.006916:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.015728:0.015728:0.005646:0.007561:0.007561:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.008166:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.006916:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010687:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041
criminal standard. This was despite the fact that the proceedings before the sheriff were civil :@0.121066:0.577484:0.872431:0.577484:0.872431:0.561705:0.121066:0.561705:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.007561:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.012582:0.010082:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.007561:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010593:0.008812:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.009437:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.007561:0.010082:0.008812:0.007541:0.005646:0.006916:0.006916:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041
proceedings, and in the absence of any rule laid down by the Act which required the criminal :@0.121066:0.593994:0.876518:0.593994:0.876518:0.578215:0.121066:0.578215:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008166:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.014498:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.006916:0.009437:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041
standard to be applied in any case other than where the child had been referred under section :@0.121066:0.610469:0.872102:0.610469:0.872102:0.594690:0.121066:0.594690:0.007561:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.009437:0.007561:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.006916:0.006916:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041
32(2) ^) on the ground that he had committed an offence. :@0.121066:0.626505:0.587653:0.626505:0.587653:0.610726:0.121066:0.610726:0.010082:0.010082:0.006931:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.009509:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.010089:0.005058:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.015728:0.015728:0.005646:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006311:0.006916:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.005616:0.005041
Classification under the Convention :@0.121066:0.642992:0.426831:0.642992:0.426831:0.627213:0.121066:0.627213:0.013227:0.005646:0.010082:0.007561:0.007561:0.005646:0.006916:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.011332:0.005041:0.011332:0.011332:0.010082:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.011332:0.008812:0.005041:0.013227:0.010082:0.011332:0.008812:0.008812:0.011332:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.011839:0.005041
The fact that the proceedings are classified in our domestic law as civil proceedings is not :@0.121066:0.659503:0.848631:0.659503:0.848631:0.643724:0.121066:0.643724:0.012582:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.008166:0.007561:0.005646:0.006916:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.015728:0.008812:0.007561:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.008812:0.014498:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010687:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041
conclusive of the question whether they are of that character for the purposes of article 6 of :@0.121066:0.675978:0.862323:0.675978:0.862323:0.660199:0.121066:0.660199:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.007561:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.008529:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041
the Convention. It provides no more than a starting point, as the question has to be examined :@0.121066:0.692013:0.872747:0.692013:0.872747:0.676234:0.121066:0.676234:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.013227:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.006916:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.015728:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.007561:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.007561:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.009437:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041
in the light of the common denominator of the legislation of the contracting states: :@0.121066:0.708500:0.789451:0.708500:0.789451:0.692721:0.121066:0.692721:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.015728:0.015728:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.007561:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.007561:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.007561:0.005646:0.005041
Engel v :@0.790668:0.708500:0.858659:0.708500:0.858659:0.692721:0.790668:0.692721:0.013227:0.011332:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041
The Netherlands (No 1):@0.121066:0.725011:0.318569:0.725011:0.318569:0.709232:0.121066:0.709232:0.012582:0.011332:0.008812:0.005041:0.014498:0.008812:0.005646:0.011332:0.008812:0.007561:0.005646:0.010082:0.011332:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.006916:0.014498:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006714
 1 EHRR 647, 678, para 82. :@0.319056:0.725011:0.548536:0.725011:0.548536:0.709232:0.319056:0.709232:0.005041:0.010082:0.005041:0.012582:0.014498:0.013227:0.013227:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005219:0.005041
The examination must begin with the wording of article 6 itself, and in particular with the :@0.121066:0.741486:0.848742:0.741486:0.848742:0.725707:0.121066:0.725707:0.012582:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010173:0.008812:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.015728:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.005646:0.007561:0.008812:0.005646:0.006916:0.005041:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.014498:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041
opening sentence of article 6(1). It provides: :@0.121066:0.757973:0.484214:0.757973:0.484214:0.742194:0.121066:0.742194:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005041:0.006916:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.007561:0.006231:0.005041
“In the determination of his civil rights and obligations or of any criminal charge against him, :@0.121066:0.774008:0.880732:0.774008:0.880732:0.758229:0.121066:0.758229:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.009457:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.005646:0.015728:0.005041:0.005041
everyone is entitled to a fair and public hearing within a reasonable time by an independent :@0.121066:0.790519:0.861687:0.790519:0.861687:0.774740:0.121066:0.774740:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.005394:0.006916:0.008812:0.005646:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.006916:0.008812:0.008812:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.005646:0.015728:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.006291:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041
and impartial tribunal established by law.” :@0.121066:0.806994:0.469091:0.806994:0.469091:0.791215:0.121066:0.791215:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.015728:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.007561:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.008812:0.014498:0.005041:0.010062:0.005041
Then there are the opening words of article 6(3) which provides chat everyone “charged with :@0.121066:0.823481:0.876558:0.823481:0.876558:0.807702:0.121066:0.807702:0.012582:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.010082:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.014498:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041
a criminal offence” is to have the minimum rights which are set out in that article. :@0.121066:0.839956:0.786887:0.839956:0.786887:0.824177:0.121066:0.824177:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.006916:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.015728:0.010082:0.015728:0.005041:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.006432:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.007561:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.005521:0.005041
There are two aspects of the wording of article 6 that I think are worth noting before I turn to :@0.121066:0.856027:0.875812:0.856027:0.875812:0.840248:0.121066:0.840248:0.012582:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.005646:0.014498:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.014498:0.010082:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.009457:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.008812:0.005041:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041
the authorities. The first is that, for article 6 to apply at all, the proceedings must be capable :@0.121066:0.872502:0.863694:0.872502:0.863694:0.856723:0.121066:0.856723:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.005041:0.012582:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.006916:0.005646:0.006916:0.007561:0.005646:0.005041:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.005646:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.015728:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.008812:0.005041
of being classified either as proceedings for the determination of the person’s “civil rights and :@0.121066:0.888989:0.883666:0.888989:0.883666:0.873210:0.121066:0.873210:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.007561:0.007561:0.005646:0.006916:0.005646:0.008812:0.010082:0.005041:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.005041:0.009205:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010687:0.007561:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.007561:0.010082:0.010082:0.006916:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.005646:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.005041:0.006916:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.007561:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041
obligations” or as proceedings for the determination of a “criminal charge” against him. Rut :@0.121066:0.905470:0.867565:0.905470:0.867565:0.889691:0.121066:0.889691:0.010082:0.010082:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.007561:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.008812:0.010082:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.007561:0.005041:0.006916:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005041:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.008812:0.006916:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005646:0.010082:0.010082:0.005041:0.010082:0.006916:0.005041:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.008812:0.006916:0.005646:0.015728:0.005646:0.010082:0.008812:0.005646:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006916:0.010082:0.008812:0.008812:0.005041:0.008812:0.010082:0.008812:0.006291:0.010082:0.007561:0.005646:0.005041:0.010082:0.005646:0.015728:0.005041:0.005041:0.013227:0.010082:0.005646:0.005041